4 ms·
> A shortage, by definition, requires a situation where the price cannot rise. This is not correct. A shortage is a situation where demand exceeds supply. The
by pdonis 10y ago
> A shortage, by definition, requires a situation where the price cannot rise.
This is not correct. A shortage is a situation where demand exceeds supply. The only definite statement you can make about such a situation is that it means the market in question cannot be in equilibrium. But there are multiple possible reasons for that. Prices being controlled is actually not one of them: the effect of price controls will not be market disequilibrium but a shifting of the equilibrium.
So the question you should actually be asking is, what is preventing the market from reaching equilibrium? Here are two possible answers:
- Demand is growing faster than supply can keep up.
- Transaction costs (for example, difficulties in employers evaluating candidates' actual potential) are preventing efficient matching of supply to demand.
- Terr_ 10y agoI find that the whole terminology/model falls apart when you get people putting the price into the definition of the thing... Whether explicitly or as an unspoken part of their argument. "The world has a severe shortage of large diamonds I can buy for pennies."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- randomdata 10y ago> A shortage is a situation where demand exceeds supply. Demand is characterized by price. Simply saying you want something does not mean you demand something. I'd love to find programmers for $1/hr, but I haven't increased the demand for programmers by saying that. I have to offer something a programmer is actually willing to take to be considered demand. And so, again, as long as price is rising, you cannot have a shortage. Every time the price goes up, there will be buyers dropping out of the market not willing to pay the new high. The result is that only those who can afford programmers will be able to hire programmers, and the supply will exactly equal the demand.
- pdonis 10y ago> Demand is characterized by price. No, demand is characterized by the quantity demanded at a given price. More precisely, the demand curve is a curve of quantity demanded vs. price. > I'd love to find programmers for $1/hr, but I haven't increased the demand for programmers by saying that. Not by just saying it, but you could post a want ad for programmers at $1/hr in order to investigate the potential supply of programmers at that price. Of course you would find that it was zero, but that just means there's no supply of programmers at that price, not that there's no demand. > Every time the price goes up, there will be buyers dropping out of the market not willing to pay the new high. Now you're assuming that there is supply--programmers available at higher prices--but not demand--clients don't want to pay the offered price. (A more precise analysis would say that the quantity supplied at that price is greater than the quantity demanded--some clients will pay that price but not enough to hire all available programmers.) You're right that this is not a shortage, but that's because it's a surplus instead--supply exceeds demand, instead of demand exceeding supply. You're also ignoring other possibilities. Programmers could decide to accept lower wages instead of higher ones. "Price" is not something magically set by higher authority; it's the output of the market, not an input to it. In the first case above, if you want a programmer you will have to raise your offered price until you find one that is willing to work at that price. In the second case above, if programmers wanted work they would have to lower their prices (on average) until enough clients were willing to hire all of them.
- randomdata 10y ago> No, demand is characterized by the quantity demanded at a given price. Okay. So, every formalized definition I could find more or less echoes this one: "Demand is an economic principle that describes a consumer's desire and willingness to pay a price for a specific good or service. Holding all other factors constant, an increase in the price of a good or service will decrease demand, and vice versa." – http://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/demand.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/demand.asp But you are telling us that demand is evaluated by interest across the entire price spectrum. Therefore, holding all other factors constant, an increase in price does not change the demand at all, as those holding firm at the lower price are still demand. Whose definition are you using here? > Not by just saying it, but you could post a want ad for programmers at $1/hr in order to investigate the potential supply of programmers at that price. Does your definition of demand always require that the buyer be so formal in their investigation? > but that just means there's no supply of programmers at that price, not that there's no demand. Which, by your early definition of shortage meaning demand exceeding supply, means that virtually everything is in shortage. The demand, as you call it, at the price of free is almost infinite for any desirable good. That leaves shortage to not seem like very useful terminology whatsoever. Why even bother using the term shortage at all when we can infer that almost everything is in shortage? And what is special about the shortage of developers that warrants all the media attention? Especially in light of the severe shortage of Ferraris, which I frequently see people expressing their interest to buy at lower prices in these discussions. I never see in the news calls to fix the Ferrari shortage, nor do I see any government intervention to try and correct the lack of Ferraris being produced. > Now you're assuming that there is supply--programmers available at higher prices I'm not sure where you got that idea. We have acknowledged right from the beginning that price can stop rising. That's kind of the entire basis of the discussion.