3 ms·
No, actually here in the United States the presumption of innocence for the accused is sufficiently strong that it is all right to publish the names of the accu
by tokenadult 17y ago
No, actually here in the United States the presumption of innocence for the accused is sufficiently strong that it is all right to publish the names of the accused. The reason that the names of criminal defendants are a matter of public record is precisely to avoid the totalitarian practice of secret trials, in which no defense witnesses come forward because no friends of the accused know that they need to come forward.
- jacquesm 17y agoThat's nice in theory, but in practice it seems to lead to trial-by-media.
- tokenadult 17y agoI know from your other posts that you don't live here in the United States. Really, truly readers of the mainstream mass media in my town understand that reports of ACCUSATION of criminal behavior are just that: reports about accusations. Some defendants are acquitted at trial, even after extensive press coverage. There is currently a businessman in my town accused of multiple financial crimes. He is still out of jail as prosecutors prepare for trial, and he still has friends, lawyers, and various forms of practical help in dealing with the accusations against him.
- jacquesm 17y agoAgain, in theory it works that way. But in practice, the accusations are front page news and the exoneration is not, if it even gets a mention at all. In the days before google that may have been ok, but now a reputation is damaged for a lifetime for prospective employers, spouses, business partners and so on that have no knowledge of the case as it happened. Every year there are more indications that prospective employers will google the names of job applicants, if something negative comes up about you there is a good chance you'll be turned down without so much as the benefit of a chance to tell your story. It also depends very much on the crime the person is accused for, being accused of some crimes is more easily 'forgiven' than others even if the person was exonerated. But try finding a job as a teacher once you've been accused of child molestation charges, even after you've been exonerated. And then there is the problem that even if you are found guilty, there may be a miscarriage of justice or, after you've paid your debt to society you are supposed to be able to start with a clean slate. If your mug is all over the internet with a juicy story attached to it then you might as well forget about starting over, which in turn might lead to recidivism.