3 ms·
This isn't quite the same as the situation with illegal immigrants. This guy received scholarships which should have gone to other students -- that is, free mo
by cperciva 17y ago
This isn't quite the same as the situation with illegal immigrants. This guy received scholarships which should have gone to other students -- that is, free money, not merely a job.
Even if this guy had gotten into Harvard non-fraudulently, he probably wouldn't have received the same scholarships without deceit.
- xor_lemma 17y agoIllegal immigrants receive plenty of entitlements.
- Retric 17y agoIllegal immigrants pay plenty of taxes as well. However, unless he would have given money to their endowment I don't think Harvard would have benefited from letting him graduate. PS: Still I can't help but wonder what would have happened if he had showed up to that "disciplinary action".
- cperciva 17y agoPS: Still I can't help but wonder what would have happened if he had showed up to that "disciplinary action". He would have been kicked out, but would probably not be facing charges. Universities really don't like to make things like this public.
- psranga 17y agoSuch as? I am honestly curious. (You will have to agree to exclude the entitlements of their children born in the US, who're are legal American citizens.)
- Retric 17y agoThe reason students are upset is a significant portion of Harvard's "value" is simply the fact that someone got into Harvard. So when people are looking for intelligent and capable people you can easily find people who where at some point above average. (And chances are they stayed that way.) Granted, it also has value as a secret handshake to get into a club of people who are over payed for what they do. Just like doctors or union workers when you restrict supply you can extract more value.
- temphn 17y ago1) If you look at the total public monies paid in vs. out, illegal immigrants are definitely (on net) tax recipients. You need look no further than California's budget crisis. Please do drill down if you wish, but a back of the envelope estimate (no income tax, only sales tax, and generally under $40k income) makes the situation pretty clear IMO. 2) Moreover, illegal immigrants are disproportionately Hispanic. Their children are automatic US citizens by birthright citizenship and thus qualify for affirmative action. This is another nontrivial preference when you look at empirical differentials in objectively measurable quantities -- like SAT scores, which have their flaws, but are no doubt among the things this Harvard senior falsified. Now... 3) Just to consider the other side of the coin, someone below said "If all that matters is that I 'came to work,' then what's the point of any rules and regulations.". Yet many of us here at Hacker News know that the rules and regulations are often simply set up to favor the incumbents, and that many influential web phenomena (e.g. Youtube, Bit Torrent, Napster, Google, Facebook, etc.) were built on just being ballsy enough to play a game of brinkmanship with the law. Sure, those are laws that many of us have disrespect for -- in large part because the guys that we're "stealing" from are the MPAA and RIAA, who have deep pockets. Similarly many who "don't care" about illegal immigration aren't big fans of the USA. They argue that "the border crossed Mexico", after all, and ancestors of (some of) today's Americans killed ancestors of (some of) today's Mexicans and took their territory, so revanchist sentiment is justified. But doesn't Harvard have deep pockets? Aren't its privileged graduates going to be wealthy and successful even if there is a fake or two among their ranks? Hasn't it been the training ground for most of the capitalist and political oppressor class? Why then the outrage over devaluing and diluting the Harvard credential? Perhaps because many of us (including myself) have paid good money for one of these Ivy degrees, and so now it is our ox getting gored rather than some remote abstraction. Let's be clear that widespread 'undocumented' immigration is not a problem for the Harvard-educated software engineers working at Facebook. But the widespread presence of undocumented Harvard graduates? That's another story altogether.