9 ms·
By using software to block digital advertising, critics say, users are breaking an unwritten pact with websites and digital publishers, many of which generate t
by mikestew 10y ago
By using software to block digital advertising, critics say, users are breaking an unwritten pact with websites and digital publishers, many of which generate the bulk of their revenue from these ads.
...
In those regions, people’s efforts to block malware disguised as online advertising has been the main motivation for downloading ad blockers.
First, "critics say" a lot of things. And that "unwritten pact"? Yeah, you wanna know why it's unwritten? Because it doesn't exist. However, the second part that I quote undoes any kind of morality tale "critics" would like to spin. Users were apparently willing to tolerate a degree of advertising (which, BTW, is a loooong way from any kind of a pact), but after a point they'll turn the tap off if there are tools available to do so.
- Nadya 10y ago>By serving ads laden with malware, critics say, websites and digital publishers are breaking an unwritten pact with users, many of which are turning to ad blockers to protect themselves. If they want to pretend this unwritten contract exists (I don't think it does) then they need to uphold their part of the deal: don't infect users with malware.
- matt4077 10y agoI've been surfing the web – and sometimes its corners the Pope wouldn't approve – for 20 years, mostly without ad blockers and always without antivirus. To my knowledge, I've never been infected by malware. In regards to the "invisible pact": I believe publishers would find more success by framing it in terms of the users' self-interest: Considering everything that's going on, do you believe the world would be a better place without The Wall Street Journal, NYT, Guardian, Bloomberg, Wired etc? Or even – for people prone to sudden exclamations of "CNN IS FAKE NEWS!", without Breitbart, Drudge, and The Intercept? If you cut out every publisher currently set up as a revenue-based organisation – would you be well informed? Is there some non-professional blogger(s) who could have served as a primary source for all the news of the last week?
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> To my knowledge, I've never been infected by malware. Congratulations; may your lucky streak continue. > I believe publishers would find more success by framing it in terms of the users' self-interest: Considering everything that's going on, do you believe the world would be a better place without The Wall Street Journal, NYT, Guardian, Bloomberg, Wired etc? Aren't they attempting to solve that problem by charging for access outright, instead of just begging their users to look at banner ads?
- Retric 10y agoI use BBC and PBS so for most news which is not advertising supported and IMO by far the best option for global news. PS: You have probably been part of several botnets, modern malware does not try and break your system.
- ams6110 10y agoI would not count on PBS for much longer under this administration.
- slipstream- 10y ago>modern malware does not try and break your system. Unfortunately, malware has shifted back into breaking systems, under the form of ransomware.
- Nadya 10y agoFunny you mention NYT [0] and The Guardian [1]. It also happened to Forbes [2] and other sites in the past, such as Yahoo. It has a name [3] because it's more common than it should be. >If you cut out every publisher currently set up as a revenue-based organisation – would you be well informed? I don't believe these publishers accurately inform people most of the time (from either politically biased side). They give an illusion of "being informed" but are you really informed if you only know half the story with countless important details left out for brevity or because the situation is simply too complicated? How accurately do you think any of the places you mentioned cover what is happening in Syria? How many people do you think are actually "informed" about what is going on? Do you think most people are even capable of understanding what is going on from a few sound bytes or even segments on the news? >Is there some non-professional blogger(s) who could have served as a primary source for all the news of the last week? Yes actually, there are. They're just much harder to find. Most news worth knowing comes from a primary source (eg: Snowden) and while media may serve as a microphone to raise awareness - they aren't inventing news. They're sourcing news and hopefully verifying those sources for authenticity. Nowadays, they seem to have a vetting problem and most of their sources are users on Twitter. When the media covers a huge event - they have people who (should) be knowledgeable on the topic discuss the topic. From my experiences, these "professionals" are rarely well informed on the topic and just have a degree in the relevant field and happen to be a contact source for the media body. "Hey, we need a doctor. Find a doctor on our contacts who is willing to speak. I don't care if he's a surgeon and this is neuroscience! Doctor is a doctor!" sort of thing. The worst of the media bodies have their news anchors speak on the topics. I honestly think people would be better informed on topics without mass-media. Because a lack of knowledge, at this point, is often better than pre-existing but incorrect knowledge. Because then they think they are informed when they actually aren't. I think that's more harmful. About your lack of malware - good malware goes undetected. If you've connected to the internet at all, I can nearly guarantee you're part of a botnet at this point. I'm probably part of a botnet at this point and I take steps to protect myself. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/mar/16/major-sites-new-york-times-bbc-ransomware-malvertising https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/mar/16/major-sit... [1] http://www.zdnet.com/article/guardian-article-on-cybercrime-serves-up-malvertising/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/guardian-article-on-cybercrime-... [2] https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160111/05574633295/forbes-site-after-begging-you-turn-off-adblocker-serves-up-steaming-pile-malware-ads.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160111/05574633295/forbe... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malvertising https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malvertising
- problems 10y agoYeah, I not only have to install ublock origin, but reek's anti-adblock killer so they don't turn it off on the machines of friends and family just to prevent the constant stream of malware infections that otherwise happen. Eugh.
- ColanR 10y agoNever heard of the anti-adblock thing before. That's nice to be aware of.
- ReverseCold 10y agoSoon: anti-anti-adblock killer.
- nyolfen 10y agoalready ahead of you: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/israblock/kekndmaoonpjhjhobkcegfaaikgnccbo?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/israblock/kekndmao...
- pavel_lishin 10y agoMy go-to analogy is that you don't get to shit in the well and then try to convince me that buying bottled water is morally wrong.
- mikestew 10y agoBecause sometimes an upvote isn't enough: Oh, man, that's awesome and I'm filing it away for later.
- ori_b 10y agoI agree. On the other hand, advertisers need to make money to survive. This means there's a shift to native advertising in response, which means they're not just shitting in the water. They're shitting in everything else too, and trying to cover up the taste. I don't know what the solution here is.
- supercanuck 10y agostop shitting in the well?
- zapt02 10y agoSo, cease existing?
- Touche 10y agoNo, get another business model that is sustainable.
- ori_b 10y agoHow much are you paying sites that aren't advertising supported right now? How many more sites are you willing to pay at that same level? Right now, as far as I can tell, advertising supported sites are out-competing sites that directly charge users, meaning that users prefer not to pay. That makes leaves advertising as the most sustainable model.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dade_ 10y agoI didn't bother with adblockers until they started auto-playing videos with audio. Now I must block them. There are many circumstances when it is not appropriate for my computer to start blaring audio and I have to search where it is coming from. So if anyone broke the imaginary pact, it was publishers with auto-play.
- paulddraper 10y ago+1 I disable the speakers on my computer most of the time, because I'm never sure what will come over them.
- sigmonsays 10y ago+1 This. I can deal with the annoying interstitial (as much as i hate it) but when videos pop up and start playing I draw the line. Its incredibly obnoxious when you just want to read a website. Also it slows down your computer too if you're low on ram...
- equalarrow 10y agoHmm, honestly, I've been using adblockers since the early 00's. It started in the form of flash blockers, since there were tons of ads that were flash back then. As humanity progressed, this included various ad networks and other human beneficiary systems. Today, it's all about blocking the anti-ad blockers. :-\ I've been amazed over the years tho how some friends and colleagues let this crap through. My wife, for instance, using Yahoo mail would stupefy me on how she could concentrate on writing emails when there are banner and tower ads animating and annoyingly blinking on the periphery of their ui. As a software developer/creator, having shit all over the screen going apeshit with animations and visually assaulting assets, was just to much for me from the beginning.
- dwaltrip 10y agoMy sister is similar, she doesn't seem to mind the ads. My Dad knows this guy at work who likes the ads and wants Google to know more about him so they will give him better ads... There must be a decent proportion who don't mind for whatever reason. I'm much more like you in my desire for no distractions so I can focus. But I would go a little further and say that I consider ads somewhat of an affront to my personal autonomy, and avoid them whenever it isn't too difficult. I much prefer researching all the options myself, after I've decided to buy something, instead of continually being influenced to believe x, y, or z by profit hungry companies whose incentives are often not aligned with mine.
- tomtang0514 10y agoI honestly don't think there're many people who is "willing to tolerate a degree of advertising" even though a lot of people say so. Enable ad blocker is sooooooooo easy compare to watching even "good" ads. A well made, non-distubing, interesting ad will become boring after you see it couple more times. In addition, non of the "ad or subscription" websites ever worked to my knowledge since install ad blocker is easy and take the benefits from both side. One of my friend made an ios game that asked only $0.99 to remove all ads. Yet according to him, only 1/10000 user actually paid.
- paulddraper 10y agoDepends. How annoying are the ads on Google Search. Yes, I know this is HN, so annoyance levels go to 11, but most people wouldn't go searching out for a blocker if all adds were not overly obtrusive.
- stonogo 10y agoThey're incredibly annoying. I have a 1080p screen. The entire first page of results on every search is ads. I've stopped using google.com because of this.
- paulddraper 10y agoPgDn One click fixed
- stonogo 10y agoOr I could just use a search provider that doesn't require a "one click fix" literally every single time I use their primary service? What's your point?
- paulddraper 10y agoMy point, as I said originally, is that those ads are minimally obtrusive compared to other ads. Most people (present company excluded of course) would not seek out an ad blocker for something so minor as PgDn.
- kevincox 10y ago"Unwritten pact" is a overly sensational but I do think they have a point. Many publishers are entirely, or mostly ad supported. Their expectation is that when you read their content you also glance at the ads. If they can't make money off the ads they can't afford to produce the content anymore. (or more likely try different monetization approaches) This sounds like some sort of deal to me. And the impact of breaking it is apparent to anyone who thinks about it for more then a couple of seconds. That being said I find that many sites have obnoxious ads (or other content) and I simply hit back if it is too much. (and I consider my tolerance quite low) The content simply wasn't worth that much to me, and I can likely find equal or better content without the shit surrounding it. Ad blockers are blunt instruments. They generally affect all sites and whitelisting is rare and based on the good part of the site, not how awful the ads are. This seems like the wrong motivators for publishers. The "turn away" approach directly penalizes sites that are unpleasant.
- nightski 10y agoIt's funny though, the ad blocker blockers that they have now actually just make me close the browser tab and go on to something else. I've realized how little value the vast majority of these sites actually offer. In fact, they actually cost me more in time and productivity than anything and I gain very little. There are plenty of services I pay for. But it probably won't be an internet news site.
- uabstraction 10y agoI've found myself doing the same thing. I am not changing my configuration for your website to get past a nag screen. If it doesn't work, I'll go somewhere else. There are very few pieces of information on the Internet that are exclusive to one source. On the other hand, do an exemplary job, and I'll seriously consider donating or buying merchandise. I've chipped money to Wikipedia, Reddit, and LWN, as well as Debian, the FSF and the EFF. Not everything needs to be for profit, and not every website is entitled to making money. If the work you do is important enough, it will find a way.
- hoorayimhelping 10y ago
- senior_james 10y ago"Users were apparently willing to tolerate a degree of advertising (which, BTW, is a loooong way from any kind of a pact), but after a point they'll turn the tap off if there are tools available to do so." The issue is that it's no longer in the hands of the users. It's in the hands of the creators of the Adblock software. They decide what is actually displayed and they even have a white list where a company can pay to get onto it. This will backfire on the people rejoicing, however. Instead of advertisements on sites, we will see entire advertisements disguised as actual content (which can't be blocked). Real journalism costs money. Plain and simple. When you take that out of the equation (because Adblock has destroyed many revenue streams), you get articles written on speculation that can be done from the comfort of an office chair. Online advertisements are one of the only ways a person without a big company can actually make a living. I've never really understood this massive push against it from Hacker news, which is supposed to be about startups and the startup community. I guess an actual path to profitability is never factored into the equation.
- CaptSpify 10y ago> This will backfire on the people rejoicing, however. Instead of advertisements on sites, we will see entire advertisements disguised as actual content (which can't be blocked). If everyone allowed normal ads through, advertisers wouldn't sit back and say "Well done everyone. Time for us to stop doing sponsored stories! Back to the old model!". They'd still be attacking on two fronts. Ad-blocking just prevents one avenue of attack. > Online advertisements are one of the only ways a person without a big company can actually make a living. So? We let people who have shitty business models fail all the time. Why don't they take one of the other methods for making a living?
- squarefoot 10y agoExactly, there is no pact here. If there was one we wouldn't have seen the rise in level of annoyances we had in the post 2k web. First it was the whack a monkey small banner, then bigger flashing banners covering all upper side of the page, then the page was shrunk and its sides were occupied by more advertising, ten came the popups followed by interstitials and other interrupting annoyances, articles split into 10 micro pages just to force the user to keep clicking, etc. Do I need to continue? Nope, that is not a pact, it's publishers using every tool at their disposal to put as much advertising as possible between the users eyes and the content, which to me makes perfectly fine doing the opposite now that the available tools have turned the table.
- ww520 10y agoThere's also a unwritten pact that companies should pay for my attention. How many times that pact has been broken when unwanted ads popped up?