4 ms·
As an aside, in trying to make a title compelling (have a person as the subject), the Times is inadvertently hurting science. This article is about a hypothesi
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
As an aside, in trying to make a title compelling (have a person as the subject), the Times is inadvertently hurting science.
This article is about a hypothesis that has some evidence in mice, but tells nowhere near the whole story, especially in humans with regard to sleep. However, the title suggests more confidence than warranted. Likely, in the near future, some newspaper will publish a similar article, except the purpose of sleep will be to remember (which is also supported by studies).
The problem is the average person will see that and think, what scientists say is always changing, and they are contradicting each other all the time. Then when they see an article stating scientists say that climate change is worsening, they will view it just like any article that has "scientists say" in the title.
- phasnox 10y agoYou should know, nobody takes the NYT seriously anymore.
- kbutler 10y ago> when they see an article stating scientists say that climate change is worsening, they will view it just like any article that has "scientists say" in the title. Actually, you should see it exactly the same way - a possibly interesting finding from probably a single study, and if you actually want to know the scientific information behind it, you should go read the science, not the newspaper, and look at multiple studies, and look for weaknesses in the study that may weaken the findings. ...especially if it is something you already believe.
- maxxxxx 10y agoIt would be nice if they wrote "A new study hints at...." or something like this. When they write "Scientists say..." a lot of people will think that this is now widely accepted science.
- squidfood 10y agoThe article starts "over the years, there have been numerous theories ... here's a new one." Then later, has the usual "other scientists say it's too soon to tell". The real problem here is the headline - but then, that's true of almost all headlines, scientific or not.
- tim333 10y agoI rather suspect the NYT readers will figure out that "scientists say" is a simplification. Climate science is a different kettle of fish where the media on both sides tend to bias things to one extreme or the other - we're all going to die or it's a hoax, where what the actual scientist say gets drowned out rather, which is a shame.