3 ms·
>Protectionism also caused India to fall behind in most major sectors for the 60 years after independence. If they had an open economy right after the independ
by dominotw 10y ago
>Protectionism also caused India to fall behind in most major sectors for the 60 years after independence.
If they had an open economy right after the independence, wouldn't multinationals have completely taken over the industry given almost everyone in India was too poor to start their own business? Wouldn't this basically be "re-occupation " by the west in different garb.
Is it fair to blame India's failure on 'protectionism' when it might as well have been rampant corruption, people divided into caste lines, choosing democracy for a poorly educated/unsophisticated/caste corrupted population? How do you explain china if protectionism is root of all evil.
What about Hindu attitudes of meekness, non-violence that are contrary to aggression of capitalism .
- codegeek 10y agoYou make some fair points even though I don't agree with you completely. Yes, the corruption and poverty has not helped but then your point about hindu attitue of non-violence being against aggression of capitalism is a bit over the top. There are plenty of aggressive Hindus, trust me :) The point is that you could blame some of it on corruption, poverty whatever but protectionism has been one of the greatest causes.
- kamaal 10y agoCorruption is again an easy animal to flog in the Indian context. The real issue here is scarcity. May we should start looking at the population problem at some point in time.
- guitarbill 10y ago> Corruption is again an easy animal to flog in the Indian context. The real issue here is scarcity. What does this even mean? That it's too easy to blame corruption? Corruption is exceedingly complex. In a large scale, it could result in policies that are bad for the majority of people, e.g. continued protectionism. Tackling the root cause will take generations until thinking changes. Scarcity on it's own makes no sense. Scarcity of what? Resources? Opportunities? Basic health care? People?
- kamaal 10y agoCorruption is a side effect of scarcity not a cause. Scarcity of everything. You might want to take a break and stay in India for a few years to understand what I'm talking about.
- Manishearth 10y agoThe whole "it is due to an accepting Hindu attitude" used to be a popular way of framing the situation that is no longer in use because experts have decided that it was indeed the protectionist policies causing this. It's also a bit offensive. It is an interesting point about what protectionism prevented. I agree. It did prevent something worse. But it didn't need to extend for as long as it did, and it still did cause harm -- as a "lesser of both evils" situation it still is not a good situation to be in (and the discussion is about whether it is a good policy to apply in absence of a "worse evil" like in the US)
- dominotw 10y ago>experts have decided that it was indeed the protectionist policies causing this. I am curious about this. Do you have a reference. >It's also a bit offensive. Sorry I didn't mean it to be offensive. I think I got that from Nehru's biography that I read couple of years ago.
- Manishearth 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindu_rate_of_growth https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindu_rate_of_growth > The word "Hindu" in the term was used by some early economists to imply that the Hindu outlook of fatalism and contentedness was responsible for the slow growth. The later economists attribute the rate to the Government of India's protectionist and interventionist policies (see Licence Raj), rather than to a specific religion or to the attitude of the adherents of a particular religion. Yeah, I get that you don't mean to be offensive there.