4 ms·
The "Cliff Notes" version is... We (Americans) expect certain wages. Producing most consumer goods is a low-wage endeavor. Bringing production back to the US l
by alistairSH 10y ago
The "Cliff Notes" version is...
We (Americans) expect certain wages. Producing most consumer goods is a low-wage endeavor. Bringing production back to the US leads to an increase in price and lower sales.
We can force the issue with protectionist policy, but that doesn't change the underlying economic realities. Bringing production of cheap consumer goods back to the US would increase prices for everybody else.
In the long run, we are better off with free trade. We get the low prices we desire. The foreign country gets to develop an industrial base on which to build a large, prosperous economy. China over the last 20 years or so is a prime example - we get $1 t-shirts, they get factory jobs that increase their standard of living.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> Bringing production back to the US leads to an increase in price and lower sales. > In the long run, we are better off with free trade. We get the low prices we desire. "I want my consumer excess, f*ck the middle class" I prefer higher prices and protectionism. Cheap goods are not a right.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoProtectionism won't bring back the middle class jobs. There has been a fundamental shift from labour to capital in recent decades, this is what has made life difficult for the middle and lower classes.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoProtectionism will push wages up, which helps those who are participating in the labor force (since Congress won't act and trickle down is a farce). Have to hold capital hostage. That's the way to success for labor, and regulation is the way to do it.
- dukeluke 10y agoThis. Lower and middle class wages have been stagnant for way too long. If protectionism isn't a good way to realistically raise lower and middle class wages in America, then what is? (Keyword: realistically. Universal basic income is impossible in our current political climate.)
- mattnewton 10y agoEducation. Comprehensive job retraining programs for engineering and construction. Then follow it up with public works investment to use this labour in the short term. Protectionism is going to work, but for america's automation industry and a small lucky few who get selected during the transition. The middle class jobs you speak of are not coming back the same way. But it won't matter because this administration will be able to find one or two Americans who still have their jobs based on their policy ignoring that the cost of goods has gone up across the board and so real wages have gone down, so the average American may not be better off.
- mattnewton 10y agoIf I were capital I would simply invest harder in automation and software. You can still claim made in the U.S.A. with cheaper unit economics than people who actually try and create jobs. I don't think a lot of those jobs are coming back. We need to invest in education for the new jobs, not try and force coal mining, car riveting, etc to be in demand again.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWe can tax the productivity from your automation. Failing that, we can replicate it and break the patents for it. There are no new jobs coming. Its time to drop the charade that retraining and hustling will be the solution.
- mattnewton 10y agoThere are new jobs coming but they don't look like the old ones. I agree with the rest. Tax and retrain.
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>We can tax the productivity from your automation. The types of people who would consider a socialized universal wage are not the types of people you just elected in. So no, protectionists aren't going to do this. They'll just give the spoils to corporations, who they are indebted to to stay in office and who ultimately produce the erroneous talking points you parrot. Trump isn't pulling the Frank-Dodd act or removing environmental regulations for you, your job, your community, or the middle class. He's doing it to please the wealthy elites who will personally benefit. These policies won't "create jobs." >Failing that, we can replicate it and break the patents for it. That wont work and then what? This is the path to a command economy that won't work either. You can't just hand-wavey some kind of robotic utopia powered by taxes. >There are no new jobs coming. Obama's time in office saw the creation of 15m jobs. We're dying for talent at my employer and constantly hiring. But no, we don't want high school dropouts who think they're entitled to subsidized wages for lazy 'make work' rural jobs. You're not entitled to a job. You have to earn it by being competitive and learning in-demand skills just like everyone else did all through history.
- Clubber 10y agoCheap good are also usually of inferior quality. Look at the stuff we made in the 50s, 60s and 70s. A lot of it is still usable today if properly taken care of. The cheap stuff we buy today is mostly disposable. The prices would be higher but the need to replace would be lower. Unfortunately we're in a downward spiral. Making cheaper products overseas lowers wages. People with lower wages are forced to buy cheap, non-durable products.
- alistairSH 10y agoPeople want cheap goods, not high-quality goods. Bringing production to the US at higher cost isn't going to change that. Possibly the opposite; in an effort to maintain low prices, quality will slip.
- alistairSH 10y agoManufacturing in the US is UP over the past decade. 88% of manufacturing jobs lost have been lost to robots, not China.[1] All protectionism will do is increase wages for engineers, who will be tasked with accelerating the pace of automation. Those shirt factory jobs aren't coming back. 1 - http://fortune.com/2016/11/08/china-automation-jobs/ http://fortune.com/2016/11/08/china-automation-jobs/
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]