3 ms·
Almost everything gets compared to cars, but I don't think most people are actually accusing those things of being car-like. I have never understood exactly wha
by chc 17y ago
Almost everything gets compared to cars, but I don't think most people are actually accusing those things of being car-like. I have never understood exactly what causes it, but some people very often read far too much into comparisons. The two things being compared don't have to be alike except in the particular respects that are being compared.
It's unfortunate, because comparisons are really useful for illustrating ideas to pattern-matching machines like our minds, but people like this make comparisons almost useless because they always lash out at anybody who makes one.
- jerf 17y agoIt's a highly pervasive cognitive bias: http://lesswrong.com/lw/vx/failure_by_analogy/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/vx/failure_by_analogy/ Granted, that link is not directly about this issue but a moment's thought shows it trivially extends to the ever-present "argument by analogy" on the Internet. (At this point, I all but flip the idiot bit on someone if they post an argument containing an analogy. Using it for a description is logically defensible but usually very dangerous. I've been trying to eliminate them from my writing and thought.)