9 ms·
I think software engineering is probably an area where academia's at the most disadvantage in studying it, because it's so applied and context-specific. A truly
by _delirium 17y ago
I think software engineering is probably an area where academia's at the most disadvantage in studying it, because it's so applied and context-specific. A truly successful software-engineering researcher would have to be at least part anthropologist/sociologist, and spend a lot of time on field work. Sort of similar to academic study of the business/management field.
Areas where you can decouple at least some parts of the theory, and apply them later, have more luck, I think. For example, Knuth does perfectly fine inventing algorithms in academia, because it's a pretty academia-friendly sort of pursuit, and many of them later do make it into the real world, so it's not totally ivory-tower.
- davidcuddeback 17y agoEven the things that academia studies that can't be entirely decoupled, such as TDD, I think can still be applied in practice. You just have to take your context into consideration when deciding if it's appropriate. What is your deadline? How skilled is your team? etc.