3 ms·
Except that the options at the time were space shuttle or NOTHING--not space shuttle or Saturn V. NASA threw in with the only folks willing to fund spaceflight
by bsder 10y ago
Except that the options at the time were space shuttle or NOTHING--not space shuttle or Saturn V.
NASA threw in with the only folks willing to fund spaceflight--the military. And the military demanded an orbiter that could do circumpolar orbits--which was totally crazy from an engineering standpoint.
- colordrops 10y agoWhat does it mean for an orbiter to support circumpolar orbits, and why is it crazy?
- Arnt 10y agoIt means being able to reach more kinds of orbits, which adds requirements. So does reentry capability. Why add those two sets of requirements to the same vehicle, see?
- Already__Taken 10y agocircumpolar doesn't make sense as an orbit. The crazy shuttle design requirement was to return 40 tonnes from a single polar orbit in 1 pass. I.e bring a spy sat back to america without flying over russia. This means a massive body to hold an object, The earth would move under the craft as it rotated. Without being able to wait for it to rotate around you need wings for the large cross-range capability to glide back to america. As KSP teaches us you can't put massive wings at the top of a rocket, without even bigger wings at the bottom. But that's got too much drag to get to space and so, the insane launch system that was the shuttle is invented. They never used this ability for the entire service life of the shuttle.
- merpnderp 10y agoWe already had the Saturn. If you're saying NASA's other choice was nothing, then it was purely political and if they'd stuck to the science the Air Force would have been told to suck it eventually. Instead NASA wasted 30 years of rocket science on a giant turd that was far more expensive than Saturn and killed a person ever 2.5 launches.
- bsder 10y ago> If you're saying NASA's other choice was nothing, then it was purely political and if they'd stuck to the science the Air Force would have been told to suck it eventually. Yes, it was political. And it wasn't at all impossible that they would just collapse NASA's budget (this was in the recessions of the 1970's), and NASA wouldn't even exist today.