8 ms·
Mozilla closes Connected Devices division, lays off 50
- Animats 10y agoSo they're laying off 50 people, yet hiring for roughly comparable jobs.[1] [1] https://careers.mozilla.org/listings/ https://careers.mozilla.org/listings/
- perryh2 10y agoIs it possible that they are collecting resumes online but never hiring or interviewing the candidates? The resumes would be used as evidence that they tried to hire Americans but didn't consider any of the applicants to be qualified. This evidence was used to file visa applications.
- keyle 10y agoThat's a pretty incriminating statement, do you have any proof?
- perryh2 10y agoRemoved, thanks. Don't want to land in hot water.
- richardwhiuk 10y agoI've seen this done for less nefarious reasons, whereby a company will keep advertising for positions, but just not hire anyone. This is because not advertising jobs is a strong negative signal that business is in trouble.
- gsnedders 10y agoAnd plenty of places will find a budget, even if there isn't one ordinarily, for an extraordinary candidate. But, as was pointed out above, this isn't a money-saving exercise, this is giving up on a field.
- flukus 10y agoMaybe they just let go of whoever was keeping that page up to date.
- acchow 10y agoYou also need to publicly post job listings for PERM labor certification (for green card) and LCA (for H-1b petition). They probably have employees that want to move off whatever visa they are on (typically H-1b to green card, or STEM to H-1b).
- jopsen 10y agoafaik job postings are aimed at a specific team, have a hiring manager and a few engineers for phone screening and interviews assigned. There is even a system for tracking candidates, and an effort to blind screener for bias. So spare me the baseless accusations. --- By the way, most employees and jobs at Mozilla are distributed. Nobody on my team shares time zone with more than one co-worker on a team of 7 engineers :)
- ianbicking 10y agoThe people affected by this closure will have the opportunity to apply for these jobs.
- Manishearth 10y agoAnd these folks will probably have a chance to switch; IIRC something similar happened during Firefox OS (I'm not sure.) In Mozilla you usually get hired for a specific position; programmers (or anyone, really) aren't liquid resources to be moved around randomly between teams. Larger companies have enough going on that if a project is shut down there's usually some other project to shift to that works for both the team and the programmer. Mozilla only has a thousand employees, so there will be very few openings to choose from based on your experience level, field, and interests. From the original CNet article: > Some affected employees are getting new roles in Mozilla, but those losing jobs get severance and job-hunting benefits, Mozilla said. Although about 50 people are affected by the cut, some might stay at Mozilla since they can apply for new positions, some of which Mozilla opened early to ease the pain of the layoffs. Also, from the CNet article: > "We have shifted our internal approach to the internet-of-things opportunity," Mozilla said in a statement, "to step back from a focus on launching and scaling commercial products to one focused on research and advanced development, dissolving our connected devices initiative and incorporating our internet-of-things explorations into an increased focus on emerging technologies." The "layoffs" aren't because of money reasons, it's just a project being shut down.
- flukus 10y agoI'm kind of sad about this because I found development for the OS to be better than for any other mobile OS, even though I've got no love for javascript. It also ran a lot smoother than android even on the potato quality phone it come on. I hope in future they can leverage their rust knowledge and give us a platform that's open, easy to develop and fast.
- bitmapbrother 10y ago>It also ran a lot smoother than android I find that hard to believe considering the reviews I've read on it.
- flukus 10y agoI know, I read the same reviews so I was pleasantly surprised. I even went back to the store a few days later and bought dad his first smart phone for Christmas. It really is quite criminal how slow android is on machines that would have been unimaginably high powered desktops not long ago. Firefox/gecko has always been great on "underpowered" hardware though. A few years ago I bought an unusably slow android tablet. This thing couldn't play an MP3 without long pauses every 5 seconds. Chrome was absolutely useless but with Firefox it became a half decent web browsing machine.
- computerex 10y agoTo say you are comparing apples to oranges would be an understatement. Your comparison went from kind of making sense to making no sense at all.
- flukus 10y agoWhich comparison? I was comparing firefox OS to android and later saying how good firefox performance is in general.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- toyg 10y agoMercifully done after Christmas, but I guess the writing had been on the wall for some time. Now let's see if Mozilla can break through the bubble and focus on what web developers really need, rather than blindly following "valleyist" fashions.
- Brakenshire 10y agoShould have been kept as a research project, and only launched for consumer devices when service workers and PWA's became mainstream, and also the new rendering techniques from servo are integrated into gecko. If we're lucky, web apps will be able to cover 50-80% of native app use-cases in the next 2-3 years. When Firefox OS was launched, it was clear they were simply not up to scratch to make a system like that viable. Especially for low performance devices.
- rrdharan 10y ago> web apps will be able to cover 50-80% of native app use-cases in the next 2-3 years Feels like this has been 2-3 years out for almost as long as "native apps" have existed. Reminds me of the first scene in "Snatch" - Turkish: What's happening with them sausages, Charlie? Sausage Charlie: Five minutes, Turkish. Turkish: It was two minutes five minutes ago.
- contingencies 10y agoIn addition, a portion of the cross-platform native development toolkits use bottled web app as their approach anyway.
- untog 10y agoI agree but there really has been a lot of progress lately. Service Workers allowing offline, web notifications, and just today I read that Chrome webapp will appear in Android as if they are full apps. The part I'm still concerned about is UI performance - it's still miles off native.
- tuxracer 10y ago> The part I'm still concerned about is UI performance - it's still miles off native. Many times needlessly low expectations of both developers and managers are the blame for this. Yes, there are certain elaborate UI effects that are genuinely difficult to do well on web. But when there's a full second lag after pressing a button, or a menu slides into view at 3fps, the platform is not the problem. A native app that has incredibly choppy, laggy UI for simple interactions wouldn't make it past many engineering managers or PMs. But when there's needlessly a full second lag after pressing a button on a web app everyone shrugs, inaccurately blames it on the web platform (instead of piss poor engineering), and it's out to production furthering the stereotype that web apps are inherently jank. As a web development community we need to stop this cycle. Web engineers need to stop building, and engineering managers need to stop approving, web apps with needlessly janky, laggy UI for even rudimentary interactions.
- icebraining 10y agoSeems weird (out of character) to be reading this from a news site rather than from the Mozilla blog.
- papayawhip 10y agoMozilla is a global company. It would have been nice to do the right thing and inform all the people affected before a public announcement, but people love to leak when they've already been let go. Shame that people might have learned they lost their job from a news site because their colleagues didn't respect a confidential memo.
- fabrice_d 10y ago> people love to leak when they've already been let go Where do you get that from? If you are a MoCo employee, email me. My email is in my profile.
- stymaar 10y agoI use to have a Firefox OS phone (the Flame), but since I broke it last july, I switched to Android and 7 month in I still miss my FFOS phone :/. Android UX is just terrible, and the interface looks so slow (my new phone is a $400 phone from 2016, compared to a 180$ phone from 2014 …)
- markcerqueira 10y agoWhat Android phone are you using? Stock Android is pretty good in my opinion but the manufacturer and carrier-flavored versions of Android can get pretty disgusting.
- 5ilv3r 10y agoUnless you are running AOSP, you are not using stock android. FirefoxOS WAS FAST. I demo'd it on single core 400mhz device and it ran circles around my dual core 1.5Ghz android with cyanogenmod 11.
- stymaar 10y agoI run AOSP on my phone, without the Google stuff. I was using FFOS for privacy and freedom reasons and I'm not giving up.
- maxlybbert 10y agoThe original announcement that Netscape would release Mozilla as open source included some FAQs, including one question along the lines of "are you going to release your own operating system?" The answer was that there was no good reason to build an operating system on a browser. If only they had remembered that!
- mevile 10y ago> The answer was that there was no good reason to build an operating system on a browser. Because Chromebooks are such a failure right.
- BoysenberryPi 10y agoAre you comparing the web now to the web then? I would even argue that Chromebooks are a pretty big flop.
- DannyBee 10y agoBy what metric?
- BoysenberryPi 10y agoChromebooks are successful as school computers, children's laptops and literally nothing else. If that was the goal then great but I've never seen someone who wasn't under 14 or a student using one.
- maxlybbert 10y agoMaybe it's where I live, but I can only remember seeing one Chromebook, and that was years ago. The fact that many people believed the dream -- including myself twenty years ago -- doesn't make the dream any more realistic. Eventually, people notice that they would like to do more things than their browser allows them to. So, yes it is true that people have been willing to migrate to cheaper, limited computers (but mainly tablets and phones; not tiny laptops). But those computers are not generally modeled after using the browser for everything.
- DiThi 10y agoThey targeted the wrong public for their first devices. There are many enthusiasts like me that wanted rather powerful FFOS devices, and would have paid for quality apps. By targeting low end devices and poor countries first, there was very little demand for app developers to release to this market.
- Apocryphon 10y agoNever mind sufficient adoption to challenge iOS/Android, what are the chances any of these other OS's even manages to survive? * Windows Phone * Tizen * Ubuntu Touch * Sailfish OS Honorable mentions: CyanogenMod, Plasma Mobile
- Omniusaspirer 10y agoMy experience with Tizen on my 2016 Samsung TV has been great so far with a pretty rapidly growing application base. Not seeing any obvious reasons why it would die on this platform any time soon barring Samsung removing it from their devices for some reason.
- richardwhiuk 10y agoThe point of Tizen isn't to succeed per se, it's to fight Google's dominance over Android, so that Samsung have more bargaining power with Google.
- eddieh 10y agoI'd honestly love to see any of these gain market share. Tizen would be my preference, followed by Windows Phone (Surface Phone anyone?). It is pretty awful that we only have two real choices. If I was in charge of either Tizen or the Surface Phone, I'd make one really nice piece of hardware for my phone OS to fight Android at the fragmentation and developer experience level.
- Ezhik 10y agoCM is dead for sure.
- soggypopsicle 10y agoWell yes and no: http://lineageos.org/ http://lineageos.org/
- pjmlp 10y agoTizen is a joke, no serious developer would ever care about it. - Branched from MeeGo - Got the BADA SDK, with its C++ dialect similar to the horrible Symbian C++ - After the Enlightenment guys joined in, the SDK was thrown away and replaced by C one - A new C++ SDK was created to appease the crowds that in spite of Symbian C++ like experience wouldn't touch pure C - Recently they adopted .NET as the new apps tooling besides C So no serious business will ever considere earning money on Tizen apps. Salfish, nice idea but didn't learn from OS/2 and BlackBerry. People don't want Qt/C++ and freedom. They want the apps their friends are using. No point in getting an OS that emulates Android when they can get the real deal. Windows Phone similarly to Tizen, suffered from the SDK changes between 7, 8, 8.1 and 10. However Microsoft has the muscle to still push them as enterprise device. Apparently some companies are actually doing that.
- fabrice_d 10y agoI don't know where journalists get their facts, but this article is terrible. 1) FirefoxOS was killed a year ago. 2) We never attempted to bring FxOS to other kind of connected devices beyond phones and TVs. If they had took the time to check the projects being worked on (see https://wiki.mozilla.org/Connected_Devices/Projects https://wiki.mozilla.org/Connected_Devices/Projects) they would have understood the activities a bit better. For instance, the device built for SensorWeb was based on a cortex-m4 CPU, running bare metal code written in Rust on top of freeRTOS.
- ebbv 10y agoUnfortunately Ars Technica is not even a shadow of the site it once was. It now reprints press releases and rumors like so many other tech sites.
- Macuyiko 10y agoNoticed this as well... Pity, cause I loved reading Ars back in the day. Do you know of any solid alternatives?
- awqrre 10y agoArs Technica used to be very bad... I thought that it was getting better in the last year or two but I guess that I was wrong.
- ebbv 10y agoWhen I refer to how it used to be I'm talking like 10+ years ago. It used to be one of the best tech sites bar none.
- binarycrusader 10y agoI'm not sure how you can make those claims; if anything, they've been even more active in reviewing hardware, etc. since they actually have better corporate sponsorship. The only thing I do miss are the articles written by Jon Stokes: https://arstechnica.com/author/hannibal/ https://arstechnica.com/author/hannibal/ But all things change, and the heady era of technological advances that we saw in the 90s and early 2000s are long gone, at least in the desktop and server computer world. Electronics has now become mainstream-consumer oriented and the sites reflect that interest, since after all, they only exist due to advertising funds.
- cpeterso 10y agoThis article is inaccurate. Mozilla canceled Firefox OS a year ago. Mozilla is now canceling the Connected Devices project, which was exploring IoT and "Web of Things" technology outside of a browser: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Connected_Devices/Projects https://wiki.mozilla.org/Connected_Devices/Projects This CNET article more accurately describes the affected Connected Devices project: https://www.cnet.com/news/mozilla-layoff-firefox-device-relevance/ https://www.cnet.com/news/mozilla-layoff-firefox-device-rele...
- mintplant 10y agoIt's worth noting that the title and URL have since been updated. Original: "Mozilla gives up on Firefox OS, lays off 50" https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/02/mozilla-ends-firefox-os-connected-device-ambitions-lays-off-50/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/02/mozilla-ends-firefox...
- remir 10y agoFirefox OS should have competed against Chrome OS, not Android and iOS. Chrome OS is the perfect OS for the masses; lightweight, very secure and stable. A lot of things that used to require dedicated apps can be done in the browser now. Chromebooks are also great machines for schools, much more practical than iPads (in my opinion) and very easy to manage. Mozilla missed the boat.
- carussell 10y agoThe thing that's probably second most upsetting about Firefox OS is this: If you say what you've just said right now, you'll be told you have the benefit of hindsight working in your favor. On the other hand, if you had the ability to go back in time to make your argument back then, even with perfect omniscience about how things would turn out, then you would have been subjected to claims that there is no market for such a thing, that you're trying to satisfy your own nerd niche itch, and whatever post hoc rationale that the Firefox product team could have (and regularly did) come up with to reassure themselves that their track is the right one.
- chris_wot 10y agoThe difference is that Google was able to commercialise and sell their product. You don't need hindsight to realise that competing in the phone markplace is the wrong place to start. You start with the desktop and then make gradual adaptions that allow your operating environment work well on tablets, phones and laptops.
- eli 10y agoThere is a lot of competition in the phone market because that's where the customers are. Desktop OSes are becoming less and less relevant.
- bobajeff 10y agoThis is true. It may not be a truth people in professional circles like to here. But PCs used to be mass market consumer products in the 90s (during the internet boom) but now Smartphones, tablets and in some cases set top boxes have taken their place.
- unstatusthequo 10y agoMy Panasonic TV from fall 2015 shipped with this crap. Number of updates since then: 0
- ianbicking 10y agoIt is inaccurate that the members of the Connected Devices team (not FirefoxOS, which was cancelled a while ago) are simply being laid off. Their positions have (mostly) been eliminated, but there are opportunities for those individuals to find new positions in Mozilla. That's a challenging position to be in (I've gone through it myself at Mozilla, frankly it sucks), but it's not the same as a blanket layoff.
- justin66 10y ago> I've gone through it myself at Mozilla, frankly it sucks Did they pay you while you interviewed for other jobs? (if not, it'd be crazy to call it anything other than a layoff)
- ianbicking 10y agoIt sucks psychologically. You still get paid, have benefits, you interview for the new position but it's not like you put your resume in the stack with everyone else. Still there's no guarantee you'll be able to find another position. But people have used this time as a chance to change their career track, and that probably wouldn't be possible on the open market. Exact employment status during this interim time is confusing because Mozilla is international and the people affected fall under different labor laws. In the U.S. where there's almost nothing is mandatory you can describe these arrangements any way you want. In Europe if you want to establish a time limit I think you have to actually give the person notice that they are laid off.
- epx 10y agoI rooted for the success of Firefox OS. They treated the developer very well -- sent me a Keon, even paid for the custom fees, just over a verbal promise that I would port my app to the platform. And the idea was fantastic - pure HTML5, like WebOS was. (At that time I was talking with some manufacturers, they had a need of including locally-made apps in their phones - their proposals were essentially giving over the app, and I would have to guarantee that it worked on their phone, and they would not give one to me!) IMHO a huge mistake was to pursue the mythical "$25 phone for the poor people". Poor people buy iPhones because this is the primary computing device they have. Lisa Simpson-like deeds, like the "bro" file extension discussion.
- dang 10y agoUrl changed from https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/02/mozilla-ends-firefox-os-connected-device-ambitions-lays-off-50 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/02/mozilla-ends-firefox..., which points to this.
- Nomentatus 10y agoI don't think Mozilla is lost - although they lost a battle. The war continues, and now it's all about Servo and Rust. Don't be too shocked if a new browser-based-OS comes out in time, too; with the new tech. The timing for such a thing is better every day as HTML5 adoption increases, etc. And remember how far Mozilla fell once upon a time before an independent effort called Firefox revived them and then some. Rust has massive advantages. I do wish they'd look over at Chromium's license and change their license terms so that they could be almost assured that they were building the future because they were building for everybody, though.