4 ms·
Why not build a well regulated state that only uses such powers in narrow circumstances? I mean, you are sort of implying that installing a neural mesh would g
by maxerickson 10y ago
Why not build a well regulated state that only uses such powers in narrow circumstances?
I mean, you are sort of implying that installing a neural mesh would give you greater exposure to injustice than not doing so, so why not just fight the injustice to begin with?
Not believing that such a state is achievable is one thing, but you did say "in this reality".
- koolba 10y ago> Why not build a well regulated state that only uses such powers in narrow circumstances? Because the definition of "well regulated" is highly subjective and any state that's in power would consider its own uses to be with the confines of any circumstance no matter how narrow. The only way to win is to not play the game.
- maxerickson 10y agoNo, the only way to win is to continually work to build a more just society. It may be pragmatic to keep computers out of your brain in the meantime.
- pjlegato 10y agoThe intractable problem is that what constitutes "more just" is highly subjective, highly debatable, and always will be. All historic societies believed they were being "more just" in some sense.
- djsumdog 10y agoI would recommend the book Animal Farm. The revolution was good in every way. It was peaceful and the animals got back control of their lives. But even from that, the pigs convinced everyone they needed leaders. Unfortunately, the pragmatic reality is that no matter how much you try to shape a system of control to be balanced, the people who eventually get into power are the ones that crave it and often don't have much respect for the individual.
- maxerickson 10y agoYes, you must continually work to build a more just society. There is no sitting back and enjoying it after you have finished it because it will never be finished.
- nilved 10y agoThere is no such thing. Absolute power corrupts absolutely and all stateful societies will trend toward dystopia.
- maxerickson 10y agoAnd all stateless societies will tend towards a state. By way of ideals, I'm an anarchist. But I recognize it isn't practically achievable.
- kordless 10y agoAnarchy requires a certain degree of viral sacredness most egos today aren't willing to practice.
- Thrillington 10y agoCould you expand on the idea of viral sacredness?
- spitfire 10y agoBecause 1930's German census and current US politics is why,. Unfortunately you have to assume the worst will happen, and plan accordingly.
- maxerickson 10y agoI would argue I am also talking about planning for the worst. Surviving while millions of people are exterminated around you is not an amazing, tremendous success. It seems people think I was arguing that they should be eager to plug computers into their brains. I was not. I was arguing that hiding while injustices are carried out upon those around you is not success.
- manicdee 10y agoFirst reason that springs to mind is that the deviation from "well regulated state" to "fascist dictatorship" is always one election away.
- LordKano 10y agoEven the narrowest of circumstances tend to broaden when it can benefit the state. "It is not that power corrupts but that it is magnetic to the corruptible." - David Brin
- apricot 10y agoWell regulated states are unstable equilibria.