5 ms·
Sigh. I like FETs as much as the next engineer but if you're going to write about them, try to not make things worse. In particular, this made me sad: the 10K
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Sigh.
I like FETs as much as the next engineer but if you're going to write about them, try to not make things worse.
In particular, this made me sad: the 10K resistor to ground isn't strictly necessary, but it ensures that the MOSFET remains OFF if the arduino is disconnected or it's pin is not an OUTPUT.
I was helping a high school student with a transistor project and he was complaining that "half the FETs he bought were 'bad'". And they weren't really bad, but they were destroyed. They were destroyed because, like our author, the student had no understanding of how the FET worked and so didn't realize that when you exceed the maximum Gate voltage on a FET it generally causes a current to "jump the gap" to the source and that permanently breaks it. What is even more, since the gate is essentially a capacitor, you can just touch the gate with your finger and pass enough charge (without feeling a shock or anything) to greatly exceed the gate voltage. Pick up the FET without being grounded and "boom!" dead FET.
Now there is almost no way to generate enough current by touching a Bipolar transistor to kill it, and so they continue to work for a long time while plugging them in and out of breadboards.
Do they dissipate more power? Absolutely. Are they difficult to run in parallel? Sure. But they are pretty robust parts. Sort of like the difference between alkaline batteries and LiON rechargeable batteries. Sure the latter are a "better" choice, you can recharge them after all, but if you use them wrong they catch on fire, if you short an alkaline battery it gets hot but doesn't go ballistic on you.
So those "antique" parts are generally very cost effective, very robust, and easy to get. So they make excellent tools to teach you the basics. Do you want to stay with them as you get more advanced? Probably not, but you're probably not skiing on the same skis you learned on either.
/endrant
- aexaey 10y agoYep. It is indeed easy to ruin a FET with minuscule amount of static charge. That is, unless there is a zener (or two, back-to-back) connecting gate to source. Many modern FETs have this built right in. E.g. ATP214 [1]. [1] http://www.onsemi.com/pub/Collateral/ENA1712-D.PDF http://www.onsemi.com/pub/Collateral/ENA1712-D.PDF
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoThat does sound like a very useful part for learning purposes, as well as general robustness, but they don't appear to be particularly common. I get no results on eBay, nor can I find through-hole packages. Do you know of anything available like that?
- mrob 10y agoNXP makes a version of the popular 2N7002 with ESD protection: http://www.nxp.com/documents/data_sheet/2N7002CK.pdf http://www.nxp.com/documents/data_sheet/2N7002CK.pdf Surface mount only (like most modern transistors), but SOT-23 isn't too hard to hand solder. There are lots of breakout boards for surface mount packages available for prototyping, or you could even solder some mod wire directly to each pin and put some hot melt glue on it to keep it in place.
- nomel 10y agoHere's a great example [1] of using static charge to activate a FET, as a proximity detector. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwC6EHah9xI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwC6EHah9xI
- PeanutNore 10y agoWhen I buy 100 BS170 MOSFETs, I also buy 100 9.1v Zener diodes for this precise reason. Gate protection diodes are essential for peace of mind when using MOSFETs.
- jwatte 10y agoAlthough I really wish there was a better alternative to the BS170 in the same TO package, because BS170, too, is old tech and has high Rdson.
- pravda 10y ago>In particular, this made me sad: the 10K resistor to ground isn't strictly necessary, but it ensures that the MOSFET remains OFF if the arduino is disconnected or it's pin is not an OUTPUT. Not sure why that made you sad (extraneous ' in its?). But I agree about the static-sensitive disadvantage of MOSFETs. Also, the author mentions that a TIP120 is not a transistor but a darlington pair (two transistors in one) but then misstates the Hfe. The whole point of a darlington is to get a high Hfe (small base current controlling large collector current) and the Min. Hfe is 1000, at least according to: https://cdn-shop.adafruit.com/datasheets/TIP120.pdf https://cdn-shop.adafruit.com/datasheets/TIP120.pdf
- ChuckMcM 10y agoIt wasn't the grammar :-) it was that the author considered the 10K resistor to ground as "not strictly necessary". It is critical if the microprocessor pin can float (tri-state). Without it, and a floating gate, not only will the FET eventually turn on, it can be damaged by excess charge build up.
- simcop2387 10y agoNot just excessive charge up it could be possible for it to be stuck in its linear region and dissipate a lot of power as it's spuriously turning on because there's a charge on the gate. I've managed to do that one on accident with a bad motor driving circuit. Though it was also largely caused by coupling on the breadboard.
- mindslight 10y agonit: It's not wrong to assert that the microcontroller software will prevent the output pin from ever floating. And the gate's voltage will be constrained between Vdd and Vss due to the output pin's likely body diodes. Is it worth it to save a penny part, especially in a hobby/prototype design? No. Also if you throw away all your BJTs, what do you use to drive the gate capacitance of your fancy FETs?
- vvanders 10y agoYeah, The Art of Electronics does a great job at covering the practical side of transistor choices and some of the trade-offs involved.