6 ms·
> Have you ever contemplated the fact that humans are the only species on Earth that pays to live on the planet? This sounds vaguely profound, until you realiz
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
> Have you ever contemplated the fact that humans are the only species on Earth that pays to live on the planet?
This sounds vaguely profound, until you realize that other species are also predated on, starve to death, and die from trivially preventable issues.
- 67726e 10y ago< predated on, starve to death, and die from trivially preventable issues. Sounds profound until you realize we are too.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoThe majority of humans have very few natural predators, and to even be exposed to animals like bears, mountain lions and sharks usually requires a bit of effort. (What's going to eat me in a city? Maybe my cat, if I die in my apartment.) And while there are more people that starve to death that should, and more people who cannot get affordable health care, I would still much rather live in the modern world than head out into the forest and try to survive by myself, or as a subsistence farmer on a manor lord's land. What animal would you trade places with? For that matter, would you be willing to roll the dice and change places with a random "free" human being living 5,000 years ago?
- hacknat 10y agoHow about rolling the dice now and ending up in a backwater of SE Asia or the DRC? I don't disagree that this is probably the best time to be alive on average, but the standard deviation is pretty enormous, and I would argue that it might not be the best time to be alive in all places.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> How about rolling the dice now and ending up in a backwater of SE Asia or the DRC? Still statistically better than a random human being in 3,000 BC. And of course, we don't live in the best possible universe; but on average, a random human's odds of being eaten by a figurative grue monotonically increase as you go backwards in time.
- chandler 10y ago>> ...a random human's odds of being eaten by a figurative grue monotonically increase as you go backwards in time. Humans don't live alone in the woods--not now, not 5,000 years ago (nor 45,000 years before that). They band together to modify, control, and tame their environment. Now, you might miss your devices, pastimes, and widespread sanitation...however, from my understanding, humans don't typically worry about malevolent grues. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatomically_modern_human#Modern_human_behavior https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatomically_modern_human#Mode...
- pavel_lishin 10y agoA grue doesn't have to be malevolent to kill you. A bobcat that bites your neck is hungry, a mis-step that breaks a knee is careless, a tooth infection that spreads into the blood is indifferent, the blood that pours out of a woman giving birth is just following the laws of pressure and gravity.
- emiliobumachar 10y ago> For that matter, would you be willing to roll the dice and change places with a random "free" human being living 5,000 years ago? We're all priviledged for being literate and having access to the internet. A more representative what-if would be to choose between trading places with a random person 5000 years ago, or with a random modern person anywhere in the world. I would rather trade within the modern world, but it's nowhere nearly as sure a thing.
- 67726e 10y agoThere are more ways to be predated on that do not involve being eaten.
- xenihn 10y agoWe prey on eachother.
- adrianN 10y agoIt's also wrong. Aphids for example pay ants in honeydew for their protection.
- jerf 10y agoIt isn't that hard to analyze ecology in economic terms. "Money" doesn't particularly exist due to (almost!) none of the participants being cognitively capable of processing it, but you do have some barter, and a whole lot of supply/demand curves based on differential valuations, as well as a lot of things that can be or are even best analyzed as cost/benefits analyses. Predation, for instance, has a big cost/benefit analysis on the cost of the energy input plus the risk of being injured vs. what the predation may produce. It isn't the same as a human economic analysis but it's another useful lens to look at the natural world.
- chrisper 10y agoI thought we are paying for convenience and not to live on the planet. Like, I could do it all by hand for free, but I am choosing to pay so I don't have to.
- smacktoward 10y agoCivilization: the ultimate in-app purchase?
- panglott 10y agoWhere are you going to sleep and store your tools?
- chrisper 10y agoIn my hand-crafted artisan shed that has hand-crafted (from rare wood) tool boxes! Jokes aside, but I think this idea applied like many centuries ago. I think I might read it in some philosophical text. So today you would not be able to do that obviously, since you need to purchase land etc. and the whole society is based on purchasing to satisfy your needs.
- DougN7 10y agoHumans don't have to work. We can sleep in the rain and hunt and gather to survive like the animals. Although I would argue hunting and foraging is work, so most animals don't get out of it either.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoAnd hunting and gathering isn't work...how? Not to mention you'd still have to make your own clothes, your own shelter, take care of children, etc.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lostlogin 10y agoWe wouldn't have to work as much if automation is done right. However it sure looks like we are going to use automation to further concerntrate wealth.
- at-fates-hands 10y ago>> However it sure looks like we are going to use automation to further concerntrate wealth. The only problem I have this statement is if you do not believe in the notion of freewill, then yes this is accurate. If you believe in the notion of freewill, then you would think instead of seeing what's happening and think that all the wealth is being concentrated into the top 1% of society unfairly, what's to stop you from being in that 1%? Nearly every obstacle you will list, I can name several people who have overcome those impediments to be successful. When you stop thinking the deck is stacked against you, it frees your mind to think of what your capable of, not of the greater odds that stacked against that will prevent you from achieving what you want to.
- adrianN 10y agoBy definition, only 1% of the population can be in the top 1%. Do you want to tell me that anybody can become part of the top 1%?
- flippyhead 10y agoYeah that seems silly, money is just a tool we created to organize our activities. It's no different than any other kind of animal behavior. This statement is just as "profound" as saying "Did you ever consider that bee's are the only animal that has to make honey just to live on the planet?" Mind blowing!
- cnnsucks 10y agoIt sounds fashionably misanthropic and I stopped reading at that point. Based on the feedback here I didn't miss much.
- protomyth 10y ago..and didn't have specialized professions that allow for all the wonders we get to experience - I like my cancer and heart specialists and would rather not go back to the tipi and chase buffalo up and down the plains[1]. 1) Dad's side, farming I guess for Mom's side
- agumonkey 10y agoI think the natural competition has just shifted up into social structures. But yeah life isn't "free" even in the jungle.