3 ms·
> the alternative I proposed is coming up with quantitative laws, not vague astrology like "Race A does this more often than Race B, therefore we need to do les
by epistasis 10y ago
> the alternative I proposed is coming up with quantitative laws, not vague astrology like "Race A does this more often than Race B, therefore we need to do less of C".
You appear to be saying that causality is not quantitative, however that is not true.
- Retra 10y agoNo, they're saying the causal relation does not add much more (quantitatively speaking) to an existing correlative relation. They're suggesting we throw out the part that distinguishes causal from correlative, not correlative reasoning altogether.
- epistasis 10y agoIf that's that what nonbel is actually saying, then nonbel does not have much experience with modern science. The difference between P(Y|X) and P(Y|do(X)) are, in my scientific experience, the difference between doing science and doing statistics. The difference between understanding and guessing. This is precisely the difference between quantitative understanding and "astrology," as they phrased it.