2 ms·
Well, your arguments seem equally non-sequiter to me. I spend a lot of time in the world of correlations, in biology. They're not so useful. It's much better t
by epistasis 10y ago
Well, your arguments seem equally non-sequiter to me. I spend a lot of time in the world of correlations, in biology. They're not so useful. It's much better to get a causation: a knob that when you turn it you get a response, rather than no response. If you can't see the utility of the two, then perhaps there's not much to discuss?
- nonbel 10y ago>"Well, your arguments seem equally non-sequiter to me." Fair enough. >"I spend a lot of time in the world of correlations, in biology." I left that field. One reason was because I realized so much of my time was wasted after I attempted to attach numbers to things like "# of receptors required to fit the narrative". Sure "A causes B", but it must be for some reason totally different from what is usually proposed (and could probably be considered a boring experimental artifact). I just don't care if "A causes B". I want to know for "f(A) ~ B", what is f? >"It's much better to get a causation: a knob that when you turn it you get a response, rather than no response." Reminds me of this paper: "Biologists summarize their results with the help of all-too-well recognizable diagrams, in which a favorite protein is placed in the middle and connected to everything else with two-way arrows. Even if a diagram makes overall sense (Fig. 3a), it is usually useless for a quantitative analysis, which limits its predictive or investigative value to a very narrow range. The language used by biologists for verbal communications is not better and is not unlike that used by stock market analysts. Both are vague (e.g., a balance between pro- and anti-apoptotic bcl-2 proteins appears to control the cell viability, and seems to correlate in long-term with the ability to form tumors) and avoid clear predictions." https://bml.bioe.uic.edu/BML/Stuff/Stuff_files/biologist%20fix%20radio.pdf https://bml.bioe.uic.edu/BML/Stuff/Stuff_files/biologist%20f...
- epistasis 10y agoI think that you would really really like modern causality research if you bothered to look into it. It's all about f(A) ~ B, but recognizes that there are different ways of varying B. Do you disconnect B from the rest of its influences when you vary it, or are you letting them vary. If you try to model f(A) ~ B in biological systems without simultaneously modeling causality, then it's going to go wrong. This happened to me in year 2 of grad school. The bayesian network built around data without modeling the causality was wrong, the one that took into account the causality from the knockout experiments was right.