3 ms·
Causality is quite different from frame of reference. Lets return to your equation. r^2 = m1*m2/F is a statement of correlation that's valid to many digits,
by epistasis 10y ago
Causality is quite different from frame of reference.
Lets return to your equation. r^2 = m1*m2/F is a statement of correlation that's valid to many digits, that also says that "these are all the variables that affect anything here." It allows for calculations of quantities by plugging in numbers. In combination with other equations, it allows extrapolitaion and physical thinking. But equations alone are not enough for a physicist to make progress on problems, they don't combine arbitrarily, they still use that famous "physical intuition" that turns out to involve a heck of a lot of causality that they talk about in the cafeteria but don't often write about.
In the world outside of physics classrooms, most situations involve a huge number of variables interacting with each other, and the variables themselves are leaky abstractions. This means that the correlation of quantities does not go out to many digits, or even one digit. This does not make an equation a useful abstraction. People have developed probabilistic models that stand in for equations in these situations. Sure, it would nice to have an equation that modeled things like they do in the simple situations that Physics publishes on, but when the equations of physics are so weak that they can't even fold a protein, how are we going to use them to model the interaction of a potential drug with a protein?
Equations are great, when they apply. By introducing simplifying assumptions, we can sometimes extend their utility into new domains, but at the cost of introducing fragility because of those simplifying assumptions. They allow for calculating new things with only a very few computations. But nearly every new field of science invents new math. One of the more recent inventions is causality. It works fantastic in those sciences that use experimental interventions. Simple algebraic equations do not.
- nonbel 10y agoSorry, all these arguments seem like non-sequiturs to me. Physicists might pray together in the cafeteria to come up with good ideas. It doesn't mean God answered their prayers when they have one. Useful laws need not be exactly correct. You can keep adjusting to stay on course to account for the error due to any simplifications. Sure causality seems like it must be at least some kind of heuristic, that doesn't mean looking for causes is the best, or even a good, use of time.
- epistasis 10y agoWell, your arguments seem equally non-sequiter to me. I spend a lot of time in the world of correlations, in biology. They're not so useful. It's much better to get a causation: a knob that when you turn it you get a response, rather than no response. If you can't see the utility of the two, then perhaps there's not much to discuss?
- nonbel 10y ago>"Well, your arguments seem equally non-sequiter to me." Fair enough. >"I spend a lot of time in the world of correlations, in biology." I left that field. One reason was because I realized so much of my time was wasted after I attempted to attach numbers to things like "# of receptors required to fit the narrative". Sure "A causes B", but it must be for some reason totally different from what is usually proposed (and could probably be considered a boring experimental artifact). I just don't care if "A causes B". I want to know for "f(A) ~ B", what is f? >"It's much better to get a causation: a knob that when you turn it you get a response, rather than no response." Reminds me of this paper: "Biologists summarize their results with the help of all-too-well recognizable diagrams, in which a favorite protein is placed in the middle and connected to everything else with two-way arrows. Even if a diagram makes overall sense (Fig. 3a), it is usually useless for a quantitative analysis, which limits its predictive or investigative value to a very narrow range. The language used by biologists for verbal communications is not better and is not unlike that used by stock market analysts. Both are vague (e.g., a balance between pro- and anti-apoptotic bcl-2 proteins appears to control the cell viability, and seems to correlate in long-term with the ability to form tumors) and avoid clear predictions." https://bml.bioe.uic.edu/BML/Stuff/Stuff_files/biologist%20fix%20radio.pdf https://bml.bioe.uic.edu/BML/Stuff/Stuff_files/biologist%20f...
- epistasis 10y agoI think that you would really really like modern causality research if you bothered to look into it. It's all about f(A) ~ B, but recognizes that there are different ways of varying B. Do you disconnect B from the rest of its influences when you vary it, or are you letting them vary. If you try to model f(A) ~ B in biological systems without simultaneously modeling causality, then it's going to go wrong. This happened to me in year 2 of grad school. The bayesian network built around data without modeling the causality was wrong, the one that took into account the causality from the knockout experiments was right.
- Xcelerate 10y ago> but when the equations of physics are so weak that they can't even fold a protein, how are we going to use them to model the interaction of a potential drug with a protein Minor nit: the equations aren't weak at all — they predict the gyromagnetic moment of an isolated electron to ten decimal digits of agreement with experiment. The weakness is in the computational implementation of those equations, i.e., solving the equations in a reasonable time. You can perform a relativistic quantum monte carlo simulation of protein folding, and I guarantee the results will match those obtained in the lab to whatever level of accuracy you desire, but you'll have to wait longer than the age of the universe for the computation to finish running. Also, for work on small proteins, the calculated chemical properties match the experimentally tested ones very closely nowadays. The problem is all of the unknown interactions that a new drug has with the rest of the human body outside of one protein. And without a large atomistic model of a human body, it's going to be a long time before simulation can solve that problem.
- epistasis 10y ago> The weakness is in the computational implementation of those equations, i.e., solving the equations in a reasonable time. You can perform a relativistic quantum monte carlo simulation of protein folding, and I guarantee the results will match those obtained in the lab to whatever level of accuracy you desire, but you'll have to wait longer than the age of the universe for the computation to finish running. This is precisely what I mean by "weak." The equation looks great on paper, but isn't so useful in practice. And the problem isn't predicting just one protein-drug binding, it's predicting the interaction with all known proteins, all molecular complexes, and the biofilms, etc. I would go so far to say that Physics with a capital P is not so useful for many physical problems at all. Where Physics is useful, it's unbelievably useful, but its domain in the physical world is vanishingly tiny. Physics kind of has the reverse problem of AI. With AI, when you finally solve a problem, it's no longer considered AI, and AI is continued to be considered a failure. With Physics, a problem isn't part of the body of Physics until it's been solved, at which Physics is now considered a great success.