11 ms·
This sounds incredibly kludgey and at odds with Apple's de-investment in macOS. (As in "reduced investment", not "divestment".) Adding massive complexity to eke
by wmf 10y ago
This sounds incredibly kludgey and at odds with Apple's de-investment in macOS. (As in "reduced investment", not "divestment".) Adding massive complexity to eke out another hour or two of battery life seems like a poor choice when there are so many things to be fixed in the OS.
- throwaway91111 10y agoIs apple divesting its mac offering? Sounds like FUD.
- santaclaus 10y agoThis seems... suspect. There are definitely serious concerns (see the Mac Pro), but given the continued yearly releases of macOS and and the (much maligned, but a company spanning effort) touchbar, it hardly seems like they have plans to divest.
- mortenjorck 10y agoDivestment is an oversimplification of the direction Apple seems to be taking the Mac. Consolidation would be a better term: trying to prune the product line into a lineup of hits and nothing else, often to the exclusion of non-mainstream (professional) users. So the test to apply is: will this enable a headline feature? In this case, if it lets Apple put a significantly bigger battery life number on the product page, I'd bet on it.
- throwaway91111 10y agoI mean, I'm not a fan of the new MBP myself, but I don't think they're ignoring professional users. Didn't their MBP sales go UP?
- nordsieck 10y ago"often to the exclusion of non-mainstream (professional) users" The allusion is to the Mac Pro, not the Macbook Pro.
- scholia 10y agoThere was pent-up demand from people who had been holding off buying the old model....
- Tanegashima 10y agoBecause you can't buy something else from the PC industry? If there is pent up demand, it's because Apple has been treating their costumeira much better than every other OEM.
- scholia 10y ago> Because you can't buy something else from the PC industry? You can, but it doesn't run MacOS or Final Cut Pro. > If there is pent up demand, it's because Apple has been treating their costumeira much better than every other OEM Or rather, it was by treating their customers worse than other OEMs by not updating their machines. I didn't notice any other PC manufacturers where the buyer's guide said "Do not buy" for all but one machine (and the exception was the slowest MacBook).
- Tanegashima 10y agoProof?
- r00fus 10y agoWhy so? A Mac is a very high ASP item - why not, for example allow iOS apps to run in macOS (using the ARM processor). Ultimately, the 2016 MBPs are a great example of why Apple needs to divest from Intel. The poor timing for Kaby Lake mobile processors and lack of low-power RAM were both Apple's reasons stated when the topic of "the MBP isn't keeping up with the competition" arises. And who's to say that macOS.next will be anything similar to the current macOS?
- wmf 10y agowhy not, for example allow iOS apps to run in macOS That's not what the article is talking about and it's a bad idea for UX reasons (no touchscreen). And who's to say that macOS.next will be anything similar to the current macOS? Don't even go there; a vocal minority of Mac users including me do not want anything like that. And getting back to the article, if the OS is radically different then presumably it doesn't need both Intel and ARM processors.
- roryisok 10y agoNo reason they couldn't put a touch screen on a MacBook or imac, though I guess they can't guarantee one on a mac pro
- __jal 10y agoWell, one reason is that touch screens for desktop OSes suck. Holding your arm out screen operations for any length of time is awful, and wiping the prints off your screen on your pant leg doesn't work very well on a laptop. That's not to say Apple doesn't release terrible things at times (hockey puck mouse[1]?), but I have trouble imagining Apple releasing one of those. (Laplet? tabletop?) [1] I actually think that may have been calculated - it is impossible that Jobs didn't know it was a shitty mouse, but alongside the iMac, it got a ton of attention at the time Apple really needed it.
- scholia 10y ago> Well, one reason is that touch screens for desktop OSes suck They work perfectly well on desktops like the Surface Studio, where you can bring the screen down to a drawing board angle. They also work well with a "desktop OS" on convertible laptops and 2-in-1s with multiple use modes including "tent" and "tablet". They're actually not too bad on real desktops with vertical screens, especially if you're standing up. (Try putting an all-in-one in your kitchen.) It would be foolish to assume that just because you have a touch screen that you have to touch it all the time. You don't. You can still use a mouse, a pen, an air-mouse, a games controller, and several other things. Having a touch screen doesn't make you do anything you don't want to do, it just gives you an extra option. It's a bit like claiming that if you use a mouse you can't use keyboard shortcuts. Really, that's not how it works....
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- xenadu02 10y ago> Apple's de-investment in macOS Citation needed. "We love the Mac and are as committed to it, in both desktops and notebooks, as we ever have been." http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/features/apple-macbook-pro-new-philip-schiller-interview-phil-iphone-ios-criticism-a7393156.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/fea...
- jsheard 10y agoActions speak louder than words, and it's been 3 years and 1 month since the Mac Pro saw any action.
- Spooky23 10y agoI think Ben Thompson had the best take on this. Something was fucked up bad in the product, and they aren't budgeted to make the necessary capital investment so soon to dig out a marginal product that nobody buys anyway.
- icanhackit 10y ago> [...] to dig out a marginal product that nobody buys anyway I wonder if they could expand the Pro desktop to be for serious gamers as well as dev's, videographers, animators etc. It'd be interesting to see what Razor and Alienware make on their systems - could it be enough to justify a presence in the high-end desktop market? As for bringing gamers to the platform, Apple already has experience with this...from the losing side at least. Originally Halo was meant for the Mac however Microsoft purchased Bungie in 2000 and much like GoldenEye for the N64, Halo was the game that sold enough Xboxes to make the platform solid. Apple would similarly need some top-tier titles to encourage people to embrace an expensive desktop. Apple's Anobit acquisition seems to be what's giving it the edge in the NVMe arena. They have experience with quiet cooling solutions. The touch bar would be good for key-mapping in games. Back-lit keyboards are their jam. They have a serious investment in Imagination Technologies Group who are behind the PowerVR architectures. Smaller, more reliable PSUs. Their austere industrial design is second to none and deeply contrasting to the garish Razor and Alienware designs. It would come down to whether there's money to be made in the area, and I suspect most serious gamers build their own systems.
- Spooky23 10y agoOn the other hand, they're commoditizing Intel further and differentiating from the competition. HP and Dell have gotten smarter and are making better devices. Apple has powerful resources in the ARM space that their competition cannot match -- they are 100% dependent on Intel, who are having issues shipping product.
- hinkley 10y agoApple has done many, many things to eke out a couple more hours of battery life. And there has always been a market for those improvements. Same with making thinner cases. it doesn't seem like much, but it sells.
- Tanegashima 10y agoEither your prove that assertion of "reduced investment" or you retract your comment. Apple haters...
- SkyMarshal 10y agoActually, eking out another hour or two of battery life at great difficulty sounds exactly like the kind of thing Apple, but few others, would do, if you think about it.
- hvidgaard 10y agoI don't think we'll see an Arm/x86 hybrid, that wouldn't make sense as they're completely different ISAs and they either need to cross translate between them, or dobble compile everything. But a heterogenous CPU certainly does make sense. A super efficient, but not particular fast core for specific tasks that are more or less always running, and the beefy full core for regular work. If it eeks out another 2 hours of battery life, I can see Apple doing it when they're redoing a CPU from the ground up.
- nardi 10y agoToo late, Apple already invented that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_A10 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_A10 The A10 is the new chip in the iPhone 7. It has two fast cores and two energy-efficient cores. EDIT: Sorry, "invented" was the wrong word. Apple is already doing that. My point was that the parent's idea isn't new.
- hvidgaard 10y agoThat is just an argument for them doing it for their laptop chips as well. It makes perfect sense from a battery life point of view.
- gcp 10y agoApple already invented that ARM already offered this (A7+A15|A17, A53+A57|A72|A73), and Android phones have been using the design for years.