5 ms·
Good to hear that the jury made the right decision on the ridiculous charges against Carmack. Sad to hear that they think a bunch of litigious assholes deserve
by modeless 10y ago
Good to hear that the jury made the right decision on the ridiculous charges against Carmack. Sad to hear that they think a bunch of litigious assholes deserve $500 million for getting a signature on an NDA.
- dvt 10y agoLitigious or not, that's how intellectual property works. It's pretty clear that ZeniMax tried to reach some kind of agreement and no common ground was found.
- modeless 10y agoIt's clear there were negotiations. It's not clear how hard ZeniMax was trying. Based on how much support they gave Carmack it seems that they really wanted nothing to do with VR and that didn't change until they started smelling 2 billion Facebook dollars.
- psyc 10y agoZenimax, an investment vehicle for Providence Equity Partners, is literally run by actual lawyers. In the early days of Oculus, Carmack tried to get them interested in VR, and they wanted nothing to do with it. Now all of a sudden Oculus is a result of their tech. They wouldn't even have the slimy case that they have, if not for the fact that Carmack and others used to work there. People can debate the legal technicalities all they want, but the plain, everyday explanation of what happened is that some lawyers figured out how to retroactively create and profit massively from a virtual non-compete that never existed.
- whyileft 10y agoBingo. First person I found in this entire thread that knows what actually happened.
- manquer 10y agoHmm.. they still paid 100m to get carmack's previous company partly for his and others talent .. they had explicit NDA signed with oculus. carmack was working on their resources and IP(doom) on company time. Carmack was critical to success of occulus. The suit also predates Fb acquisition It is not their problem that Fb didn't do due diligence.
- elastic_church 10y ago> Sad to hear that they think a bunch of litigious assholes deserve $500 million for getting a signature on an NDA. Wait, so if the guy actually abided by the contract he AGREED to, you know as a trustworthy reliable integritable individual, then Zenimax would have the first mover advantage and market lead on this burgeoning market. In this parallel reality that has nothing to do with their ability to execute. They were deprived of that, in actual violation of an actual contract, and you find this aggregate decision of a jury sad? You are kidding right? Typically NDA's stipulate damages and punitive damages, as trade secrets are protected in the United States. The punitive damages are intended to deter someone from doing the same action again. Damages are calculated by extrapolating market value of secrets disclosed.
- jandrese 10y agoI would be more sympathetic to Zenimax if they had shown any interest at all in VR. Remember Carmack left the company because he couldn't get any traction on VR, even after demoing goddamn DooM on it. To show you just how much Zenimax cares, go and try to buy DooM VR for any platform.
- Impossible 10y agoAlthough this was the case when the lawsuit was filed, Zenimax has since promised more support for VR than many AAA game publishers, and they announced versions of Fallout 4 and DOOM for VR at their E3 press conference in 2016. Although you cannot buy Doom or Fallout VR now, they have shown both VR experiences (running on Vive at Gamescom and PAX), and are promising full VR support for Fallout 4 in the future.
- modeless 10y ago> Zenimax would have the first mover advantage and market lead on this burgeoning market Bullshit. Zenimax leadership wanted nothing to do with this market! First mover advantage is the opposite of how they work as a company. If it was up to them they would have had Carmack work on something less risky like the 10th installment in one of their IPs, and nothing would have happened.