19 ms·
Classic NES Series Anti-Emulation Measures
- kibwen 10y agoI find it very interesting to read about these sort of tactics, given that not only does their design require a high degree of expertise with console hardware (which Nintendo's developers obviously have), but also a high degree of familiarity with emulators themselves in order to understand the techniques that are likely to defeat the common optimizations and shortcuts that emulators make in order to make up for the discrepancy in speed.
- eric_the_read 10y agoFrom the "Dolphin Progress Report" article (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13544514 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13544514): there were two Disney games that wrote garbage data to a region of memory where important data was stored, but not enough to cause the CPU to flush the cache, and then invalidated the cache, causing the writes to never actually happen on real hardware, but on Dolphin (which didn't actually implement a CPU cache in its emulation layer), it caused the writes to actually happen.
- jedimastert 10y agoThat's super clever
- LoonyBalloony 10y agoAll this effort to claim possession over something. Imagine if all the effort regarding possession and wealth were used to make something actually useful. What a waste.
- pasiaj 10y agoI actually believe the exact opposite. That so many useful innovations are lost & forgotten, because there was no incentive to market & distribute the innovation. It is lost on many, that the usefulness of an idea does not guarantee it's popularity. It is very, very hard to get visibility & traction for even the most useful of inventions. Protections on ownership & wealth create the incentives to invest in creating new innovations, but also to productise, distribute and market those innovations. It is only a small fraction of products that can exist without the proper incentives to build out the whole chain from idea to r&d, productisation, to distribution & marketing.
- ajamesm 10y agoRun the Jewels just released their latest album entirely for free, and hit #1 in sales anyway, so
- Groxx 10y agoThat a counterexample exists doesn't really impact the claim that "many" (though they imply "most" imo) do not work this way.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoIndeed: Not everybody is the kind of person who pays for Jonathan Coulton's music instead of downloading it for free.
- eon1 10y agoRTJ also have an established brand - I can tell you 100% I only know of them because of their previous marketing, I've maybe heard one song. It's like how Radiohead did a pay-what-you-like for their album and it came out being viable, it only works because of their previous commercial success through more traditional routes. If they'd self-produced and made Pablo Honey PWYL they'd probably be unheard of.
- oddstorms 10y ago>I believe the exact opposite There's no belief system here. You are confused by propaganda. What you think is factually wrong and just about any example in history quickly proves this. No matter which example we consider, it contradicts what you wrote exactly.
- khedoros1 10y agoI believe somewhere in between. The usefulness of an idea doesn't guarantee its popularity, but it also doesn't guarantee its profitability, or the timeline where it will become popular or profitable.
- jedikv 10y agoThe fashion industry seems to do fine with relatively little draconian protections - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zL2FOrx41N0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zL2FOrx41N0
- ClassyJacket 10y agoA ridiculous portion of GDP is wasted on this type of hostility. Just look at how much marketing is completely unnecessary, but billions are spent on it. Look at how many companies are spending money to reinvent the wheel constantly instead of sharing code, designs, etc. Patent lawsuits. We're just scratching the surface here. It's a depressingly wasteful and hostile world.
- NTripleOne 10y agoAye, it's tough to see it as anything but a waste too - it gets bypassed and that's it, all time, effort and money that went into it was effectively for nought.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- oddstorms 10y agoPerfect summary of what's wrong. I often wonder what would happen if the best minds were trying to solve the world's problems instead of getting people to buy things they don't want.
- AceJohnny2 10y agoThat is awesome. I'll have to remember that one.
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoArticle is from 2014. Suggest adding info to submission title.
- jpfau 10y agoIndeed, I even posted it back then: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8808754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8808754
- webreac 10y agoI wonder if these tricks to defeat emulators have the opposite effects. They give truly interesting chalenges that can motivate talentuous developpers.
- brokenmachine 10y ago> talentuous I like the word, but I think you mean "talented". :)
- derefr 10y agoYep. See, for example, 4am's cracks of the Apple II software collection (https://archive.org/details/apple_ii_library_4am https://archive.org/details/apple_ii_library_4am), done half for the sake of preserving old games, but also half for the sake of discovering (and documenting!) the many kinds of anti-piracy measures that went into them.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoYeah, ironically, they could lead to the emulator developers more accurately emulating the original hardware. Then other games may actually emulate better! It's not be practical to actually make one, but theoretically, there's nothing you could do to stop your game being on a 100% accurate emulator. And some good emulators are amazingly close.
- gp2000 10y agoIt is difficult to take a binary program and establish intent. I'd rather call these "interesting and unusual programming tricks" than "anti-emulation measures" until more evidence is presented. Mirrored memory is a side effect of unconnected lines on the address bus thus making the content of those bits irrelevant. Code can take advantage of this to run faster or put tag values into addresses. On a GBA, VRAM is faster than ordinary RAM. Programs can do well to use it for tight inner loops. Using STM (store multiple) to DMA registers? Again, go faster. Save type masquerading might be code that helps when running on a development kit, but I admit that I can't think of what use it might have. Self-modifying code that depends on the pre-fetch queue might be the best place to look for intent. Might be easy to tell if the program is doing it for some larger purpose or simply to fail subtly or overtly if it sees unrealistic processor behavior. Any why would a program do extra work writing to an audio FIFO than need be?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- crooked-v 10y agoParticularly given the "NES Classics" line, I would expect weird stuff to happen because these cartridges are effectively themselves emulations of games from different hardware.
- tiraniddo 10y agoI'd take a guess that the save tricks might be more anti piracy. After all the gba had flash carts, perhaps these carts contained sram and eeprom so checking for it was to block it. No idea about the pipeline stuff though, perhaps checking vram was working correctly?
- david-given 10y agoYeah, putting tight loops into fast RAM for extra speed is a very old trick --- I've done it myself. Likewise multiple stores. Using a non-standard copy of the address --- well, it's an emulator, on a slow system; the ARM requires 32-bit constants to be read from a constant pool. If it can use certain addresses that are cheaper to construct, somehow, that'd be a performance boost. Can't tell without knowing which addresses, though. My first thought on the save type masquerading and the pre-fetch queue testing is that it's testing for particular hardware. e.g. if it's running on a cart with SRAM, do the SRAM thing, otherwise do the flash thing. Likewise, testing the pipeline size might be trying to figure out what processor there is. That doesn't explain why it just crashes rather than following some other code path --- if the code to do the SRAM thing was there, and the emulator tells the game that there's SRAM, then the emulator should see the game doing the SRAM thing. It might be something as trivially stupid as that the game contains the code to check for development hardware, but that the run-time support for the development hardware isn't present and instead the game is just crashing. There may not be anything malicious here. If I wanted some sort of antipiracy or antiemulation feature, I wouldn't put a big obvious crash up front. Instead I'd introduce some sort of random failure elsewhere in the game, so it superficially looks like it's working, but isn't any fun to play...
- patmcguire 10y agoWhy bother? If these are ports of NES games, couldn't they just emulate the NES versions?
- patmcguire 10y agoWelp, I commited the sin of posting before reading. That was the last paragraph of the article.
- jonawesomegreen 10y agoPart of me wonders if this is just some experienced game dev working on a boring porting project that decided to have a little fun and see how he could cause issues with emulation, not some large sanctioned measure to defeat emulation software. Might explain why this effort went into such a seemingly unlikely game.
- rhinoceraptor 10y agoIf I were a game dev, I would want my work to be preserved past the life of the specific hardware it was written for. It's sad that so much culture is lost due to proprietary hardware and software.
- brokenmachine 10y agoTrue. I recently "bought" Titanfall 2, on DVD. I put "bought" in quotes because I wonder how much I actually own it, if at all. It wouldn't run at all without first connecting to the internet and downloading multiple gigabytes of updates. I wonder what would happen in the future when EA decides to shut up shop or change their DRM platform. Will I ever be able to play it again? This is why I often feel like pirates "own" the content more than legitimate buyers.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoYeah. Compare this to the 90s games I've been playing: I can still take a copy of Q3A or UT from '99 and install it on my computer (although why you wouldn't use the IOQ3/UTPG patches is beyond me). Ditto for Doom and Descent (although you need a src port). Thief, Deus Ex, System Shock 2, and Baldur's Gate are a little harder to get running (you have to use wine, and in the case of Deus Ex, figure out how to get the shoddy programming to work with modern hardware), but it's still doable. Will that be true of FTL, Bastion, Shadow of Mordor, Limbo, or Assassin's Creed?
- Endy 10y agoDeus Ex works fine on my PC - though I have (I think) the New Vision mod as well.
- bondjsbond 10y agoDoes Legend of Zelda: Minish Cap have something similar? I played that game on a raspberry pi but it always freezes and dies when I enter a certain room in the final boss castle... Not sure if just a bad port or a security feature... I would love to finish it, but don't feel like replaying the rest of the game just for the ending...
- voltagex_ 10y agoWhich emulator?
- bondjsbond 10y agoI want to say it was running Retro Pie? Edit: I don't have it with me, but I think it was the mGBA emulator, sorry.
- jpfau 10y agoThat's not an emulator, it's a frontend. You'd need to know the core, e.g. mGBA or VBA-Next.
- khedoros1 10y agoRetroPie is a collection of emulators (and also distributed as a special-purpose Linux distro), mostly ported to the libretro API, and all being accessed through the emulationstation GUI. For GBA emulation, RetroPie has the choices of "gpSP" (either through libretro or independently), "vba-next", and "mgba". edit: Sorry, jpfau, saw yours after refreshing.
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoI've been reading about the gameboy's architecture and internals (in the hopes of making a game with it), and it's pretty amazing how much specialized hardware there was in earlier generations of consoles, especially compared to the more general modern consoles. And yes, new consoles have GPUs, but those are everywhere. Your computer has a GPU. It probably doesn't and didn't have scrolling registers or hardware sprites (unless, like the C64, it had a gaming focus).
- iflowfor8hours 10y agoThere is an excellent video from 33c3 about Gameboy internals and all the wonderful tricks that can be utilized when writing software for it. https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8029-the_ultimate_game_boy_talk https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8029-the_ultimate_game_boy_talk
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoC3 never ceases to surprise me. Thanks!
- derefr 10y agoOne could at least describe the "text mode" of VGA/CGA/EGA video hardware as actually being the same kind of "tile mode" you find in consoles. And in slightly more modern video cards (the kind you'd find in a Windows 95/98 machine), the mouse cursor was usually a hardware sprite. (Even today, mouse cursors seem to frequently escape OS gamma correction for some reason...)
- rahimnathwani 10y agoMy first computer was an Acorn Electron, and that had hardware scrolling, too. I don't think it had hardware sprites, but game programmers of that era often used compiled sprites to improve performance.
- kalleboo 10y agoAnd even without a dedicated scrolling register, John Carmack famously managed to get the IBM PC to do scrolling by manipulating the screen buffer address (and emulating sprites by manually redrawing those parts) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptive_tile_refresh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptive_tile_refresh
- derefr 10y ago> I’m not really sure why Nintendo went all out with these games, considering that these are just ports of NES games. I've always suspected that Nintendo cares a lot less about PC emulation, than it does about mostly-chip-compatible knock-off hardware. Think of those consoles you see at Walmart that claim to come with "100 games built in!" Those frequently contain chip-compatible designs of Nintendo's old hardware, and a library of ROMhacks of NES games (or the ROM from a single one of those 100-in-1 NES carts.) They're not emulating Nintendo ROMs; they're just running them, directly. The manufacturers of these consoles never bothered to clone newer ones after the NES, because all the demand for these knock-offs seems to be some weird combination of nostalgia and clueless-parent value-purchasing (e.g. "oh hey, it has Super Mario Bros on the box! That game was great. My kids would like that!") But the GBA is just as easy to clone the internals of as the NES is (ARM7 cores are just as easy to find—and cheap—as 6502s), and has a far larger library of games (~17000!) So if these companies could transition to a GBA chip-compatible design and still ship these NES ports, they'd increase value immensely, while still being able to put NES nostalgia on the box. And so, for these ROMs that might have been just the thing to spark this switch-over, Nintendo went to some extra effort. It would have been funny, had any of these knock-off manufacturers already finalized a hardware design based on tests with other GBA ROMs and started up their logistics pipeline to assemble consoles, had they flashed one of the NES Classics ROMs onto their new-off-the-line console, and realized that it was far more stringent than other games were about faithfulness to the GBA's architecture. It might be enough to kill a whole company. --- Of course, none of this ever materialized, because for some reason, the knock-off manufacturers are still just making consoles that are chip-compatible with NES games, rather than speccing out builds based on what chips have become equally cheap since then. Who knows why.
- einr 10y agoOf course, none of this ever materialized, because for some reason, the knock-off manufacturers are still just making consoles that are chip-compatible with NES games, rather than speccing out builds based on what chips have become equally cheap since then. Who knows why. Actually, there are now quite a few Chinese GBA clones on the market, and my understanding is that they do not use emulation but are hardware-compatible reimplementations of the GBA hardware. Some examples: http://www.k1gba.com/ http://www.k1gba.com/ http://exeq.ru/produkcija/pristavki/detskie/gamebox.html http://exeq.ru/produkcija/pristavki/detskie/gamebox.html http://obscurehandhelds.com/2010/08/the-nintendo-game-boy-advance-clone/ http://obscurehandhelds.com/2010/08/the-nintendo-game-boy-ad...
- Fej 10y agoIf I remember correctly, Nintendo also implemented tough DRM like this for the GBC Video series. Same light gray cartridges, I think. (GBA Video was a short-lived series of video content available on GBA carts. I remember having a cart with an episode of The Fairly Odd-Parents on it. The video quality was terrible. Nothing worth protecting.)