3 ms·
Modern conservative communication (I'm talking about younger conservative movements - The_Donald, Breitbart, you name it) doesn't generally care what race or ge
by pavlov 10y ago
Modern conservative communication (I'm talking about younger conservative movements - The_Donald, Breitbart, you name it) doesn't generally care what race or gender or orientation you are, and will attack or praise you based on your ideas alone.
That sounds great.
Here's a random Breitbart news item that involves Michelle Obama and Stevie Wonder:
http://www.breitbart.com/big-hollywood/2017/01/12/stevie-wonder-serenades-michelle-obama-final-tonight-show-appearance/ http://www.breitbart.com/big-hollywood/2017/01/12/stevie-won...
Look at the comments. Can you explain how the vicious attacks on her (and him) are based on ideas alone?
- beaconstudios 10y agocould you highlight some particular comments that you think are bad? All I see that could be deemed offensive is references to Stevie Wonder being blind, and bad puns linking his physical blindness to saying that Michelle Obama is "lovely". Suggesting that a blind man is physically blind is just stating a fact, and making a pun around that is exactly the offensive humour I mentioned earlier. I may have missed some stuff that's lower down though.
- pavlov 10y agoHere's some I collected in a few minutes, until I couldn't take it any more. Most of the 600+ comments are like this. "He didn't see the bulge in the First Yeti's crotch, so it all worked out!" "- So much for the story of blind people's other senses improving. He couldn't smell her bile?" "- Or jock sweat?" "Those who have seen a Sasquatch up close and personal say the stench is the first thing you notice. I think the real reason Trump is staying in NYC for the time being is to give Stanley Steamer time to get all those Cleveland Steamers out of the drapes." "They made the decision to throw the drapes away! Also paint the entire place with anti-Wookie stench paint for Purina's paint division." "Does he know he's serenading to a man?" "If he could see her...he'd likely puke and gouge his eyes out." "Yup, anyone who thought he might be faking it can rest assured, he's as blind as a bat." "He can't see the Wookie!" ""Isn't she ape-y" just doesn't have the right ring to it." "A little Braille on Micheal might answer a few questions." "Just give Mikey a quick cup check. Besides, Stevie ain't blind." "Well, to be honest, they HAD to use Stevie. Anyone else would've been turned to stone." "Serenading Chewbacca, how precious." "Stevie wonder has no idea how lucky he is to be blind singing for that sow or correction boar..." "You know how blind people feel a persons face to get an idea of what they look like? Stevie did that and asked "who let the wookie in!?" "Wonder performed his hit songs “Isn’t She Wookie” and My Wookie Amour,” changing the lyrics to the latter song to include “My Michael Amour” while the First Wookie looked on."
- beaconstudios 10y agolooks to me like a bunch of offensive humour centered around the idea that Michelle is unappealing, the conspiracy/meme/joke that Michelle is actually a man (based on her being more masculine than Barack), and the fact that Stevie Wonder is blind. What's so horrifying about that? The idea that joking about a woman being masculine is transphobic and/or sexist is a left-wing concept, and something that the modern right definitely doesn't agree on. Same with jokes about Stevie Wonder being blind - you wouldn't act indignant if a comedian made a joke about it on-stage (or at least, the majority of the population wouldn't) but it's unacceptable when the joke is made by an individual? I think the issue of perception is rooted in deeply-held left beliefs that the right doesn't share. You think referring to Michelle as "ape-y" is racist because a core progressive tenet is that racism is a constant undercurrent of modern society, and that it's somehow the core motivator of anyone who isn't a progressive. Thus, you are looking to make the connection between conservative and racist. All these comments are, is mockery aimed at left-leaning individuals. The focus of the modern right on humour (driven by things like 4chan, South Park, and so on using humour to criticise the left) is such that you often find jokes and circle-jerking mixed in with critique and discussion.
- pavlov 10y agobeaconstudios, your reply is marked dead, but I want to comment on some points you made there. I'm really trying to understand what you're thinking. You wrote: "looks to me like a bunch of offensive humour centered around the idea that Michelle is unappealing" It's obvious to me that the "jokes" are about her being a black woman. "All these comments are, is mockery aimed at left-leaning individuals." How do you know that? How can one distinguish between actual racism and nudge-nudge-wink-wink "mockery at left-leaning people", if they look the same? Previously you blamed me of automatic attribution. Aren't you the one attributing some kind of positive ironic/humorist twist to these comments, even when there's no objective evidence of such? Can you just wave away any kind of cruelty and bullying by assuming it's a joke? In programming terms, I think of racism as duck-typed, and these comments definitely "implement the interface", so to speak. I guess you must think of racism as somehow statically typed... But I'm at a loss to understand how anything could be racism, if this isn't. (Besides, I don't understand what Mrs Obama ever did to deserve this level of meanness. As far as public figures go, she was a model of grace and compassion.)