4 ms·
>I'm not going to allow them to smoke. Same can be said for any dangerous activity. Like bicycling? As long as I pay for health care, I'm not going to allow yo
by Clubber 10y ago
>I'm not going to allow them to smoke.
Same can be said for any dangerous activity. Like bicycling? As long as I pay for health care, I'm not going to allow you to do it. Driving? Hell no! You need to walk, and you can't use roads or sidewalks near roads. Only the rich can use roads, we're putting on a driving tax.
- alkonaut 10y ago> Same can be said for any dangerous activity. Like bicycling? As long as I pay for health care, I'm not going to allow you to do it. Exactly like bicycling. However, bicycling has positive benefits - it gets people places (as does driving), it provides excercise etc. So a reasonable compromise might be requiring a helmet while cycling, which lots of countries does. That reduces the costs of injuries to a point where it's likely to be outweighed by the positives. > Only the rich can use roads, we're putting on a driving tax. Cars do have very expensive side effects (injuries in car accidents, pollution, lack of excercise, ...). I pay a 25% VAT on a car. Then I pay a yearly car tax of $100 year and around $2/mile in fuel taxes. That still is probably not enough for cars to "pay for themselves".
- Clubber 10y agoNo comparison to the cost of a bicycle helmet and the taxes levied on cigarettes. Depending on where you live, how about $50 a week to rent a government approved bicycle helmet? It's starts to sound much more unreasonable when you compare the taxes.
- alkonaut 10y agoI'm not sure what the costs to society of bicycle accidents vs lung cancer are, but if the equilibrium was $1000 per pack I wouldn't consider that unreasonable (although at that price black markets would become an issue)
- Clubber 10y ago>but if the equilibrium was $1000 per pack I wouldn't consider that unreasonable Ok, so you still haven't solved the problem, you aren't collecting any revenue, and now you have a pretty serious black market and all the crime, policing costs, jail costs and bribes that go with it. At what point do you realize it's bad policy to tax sin and really only succeeds in getting revenue from predominantly poor people? 1. You will never get all people to stop smoking. 2. Any effort to squeeze down the last 15% or so is the same folly that got us into the drug war. 3. The only thing you can reasonably do as a nation is to keep pushing out the commercials and hope for the best. Quit taxing the crap out of poor people. Quit acting like smoke is mustard gas.
- alkonaut 10y agoAs I said - I'd consider it reasonable but I acknowledge the practical problems with it. I think prices a pretty good as they are in e.g Australia and Scandinavia.