3 ms·
Everyone releases stuff into the air that effects others, from perfume to car exhaust to barbecues. Why is your car exhaust ok but not my cigarette smoke?
by flukus 10y ago
Everyone releases stuff into the air that effects others, from perfume to car exhaust to barbecues. Why is your car exhaust ok but not my cigarette smoke?
- grzm 10y agoThere are legal limits placed on exhaust. VW is one recent example of this. If I were to pump exhaust from my car into your home, I'm sure there would be repercussions. I believe there are regulations with respect to perfume as well— yup, there are ADA guidelines in the US[0]. I can imagine cases where barbecues have been considered a nuisance. Found an example of that, too.[1] When looking up the phrase "my rights end where yours begin", I came across the much more colorful "Your liberty to swing your fist ends just where my nose begins". I don't think the freedom to emit noisome or noxious fumes is quite as unlimited as implied by your comment. [0]: https://www.laborlawcenter.com/education-center/new-ada-guidelines-for-fragrance-sensitivity/ https://www.laborlawcenter.com/education-center/new-ada-guid... [1]: http://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/2015/07/27/florida-county-tells-resident-to-keep-barbecue-smoke-in-his-own-yard.html http://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/2015/07/27/florida-county-... (includes autoplay video, sorry)
- sanswork 10y agoIf you wanted to run your exhaust next to me in a restaurant I'd complain about that. If your exhaust pipe was pointed at my face on the sidewalk again I'd complain. A lot of offices have gone to perfume/cologne free because it is offensive to a lot of people. Of course you still have to smell the person who just finished a smoke outside which is far worse than even the most liberal applier of perfume.
- flukus 10y ago> If you wanted to run your exhaust next to me in a restaurant I'd complain about that. That's fine, I'm not a fan of smoke in restaurants or indoors anyway. It's already banned here. > If your exhaust pipe was pointed at my face on the sidewalk again I'd complain. This is exactly what cars are doing on the sidewalk. It's not like the emissions travel in a straight line. No one is blowing smoke directly at you either. > A lot of offices have gone to perfume/cologne free because it is offensive to a lot of people. Never heard of this.
- sanswork 10y ago>This is exactly what cars are doing on the sidewalk. It's not like the emissions travel in a straight line. No one is blowing smoke directly at you either. This is wrong go walk on a sidewalk near a smoker and you'll see them blowing clouds which go in peoples faces as they walk by and leaving clouds in the faces of people walking behind them. This isn't an issue of being in the vicinity of the smoke it is having to walk through the cloud of it. Go outside an office building around 9, 10:30 or lunch time and you'll often have to walk through a large cloud as all the smokers hang out to get in their smokes. Smokers are in general super inconsiderate about their additions effect on other people in public. >Never heard of this. Google scent free office or fragrancy free office it's not uncommon these days.
- flukus 10y ago> This is wrong go walk on a sidewalk near a smoker and you'll see them blowing clouds which go in peoples faces as they walk by and leaving clouds in the faces of people walking behind them. This isn't an issue of being in the vicinity of the smoke it is having to walk through the cloud of it. The only difference is the visibility, just because you can't see car exhaust doesn't mean it's not there. > Go outside an office building around 9, 10:30 or lunch time and you'll often have to walk through a large cloud as all the smokers hang out to get in their smokes. Yes, because it's about the only area left to go for a smoke. It's an effect of banning it everywhere else, not smokers being inconsiderate. If there was a nice out of the way area where smoking was allowed then people would go there.
- sanswork 10y ago>The only difference is the visibility, just because you can't see car exhaust doesn't mean it's not there. The only difference is proximity as I already mentioned. >If there was a nice out of the way area where smoking was allowed then people would go there. There are lots of out of the way areas in most cities for people to go smoke. But still you'll find them huddled outside the entrances to buildings or as close as they are allowed to be. As I said. Smokers are selfish and will try to justify every negative impact of their addiction on others. They aren't being inconsiderate about smoke you're forcing their hand. They don't want to litter but it's your fault for not providing ash trays, etc, etc. I smoked for 20 years and I've heard countless reasons from smokers for being inconsiderate but they all basically boil down to selfishness.