3 ms·
Yes, clickbait. The "invisible force" here is gravity. This is the key bit of context: > When describing the gravitational dynamics in co-moving coordinates,
by mirimir 10y ago
Yes, clickbait. The "invisible force" here is gravity.
This is the key bit of context:
> When describing the gravitational dynamics in co-moving coordinates, by which the expansion of the Universe is factored out, underdensities repel and overdensities attract.
So it's basically a coordinates transformation thing.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mirimir 10y agoUpon reflection, Hoffman et al. (2017) itself may arguably be clickbait. To the extent that I understand it, they're looking at inhomogeneity in cosmic expansion. It seems equivalent to turbulence in fluid dynamics. That is, non-uniform flow. And in considering airflow, for example, one doesn't say that underdensities repel air, or that overdensities attract air. Rather, it's the non-uniform flows that create the underdensities and overdensities. Anyway, it seems to me that Hoffman and coauthors should have stuck to describing correlations, because that's all they have. Using the language of causality is confusing. They don't mention it, but maybe they have an agenda to promote varieties of dark matter with positive and negative gravity.
- mannykannot 10y agoI don't think the analogy holds, because the gravitational force between molecules is not significant in airflow.
- mirimir 10y agoFair enough. But what about the causality issue?