7 ms·
And it's a regressive tax that mostly punishes the poor for smoking. Not to mention the ridiculous prices of alcohol. It's no wonder meth is exploding in popula
by flukus 10y ago
And it's a regressive tax that mostly punishes the poor for smoking. Not to mention the ridiculous prices of alcohol. It's no wonder meth is exploding in popularity.
It's an easy way to evaluate the real priorities of politicians though. If cost of living issues were really their number one priority then these sin taxes would be the first to go.
- chris_wot 10y agoIt certainly is a regressive tax, but is it really punishing someone if you make it more expensive to legally purchase something that only damages or kills them, is highly addictive and that only places an overall burden on society? After all, despite its flaws we in Australia have a great, free healthcare system, with an extensive quit smoking program. We tend to find that adequate and free government health services mean that the poorest in our society are looked after far better than in a society that has cheap booze and cigarettes and an incredibly expensive healthcare system. I guess it depends on the priorities of your wider society. I think ours is pretty right, personally.
- flukus 10y agoDepends on how the calculations are done but it can be shown to save money overall. Smokers have a tendency to die much younger and more rapidly which saves the health and welfare budget a tonne, smokers are certainly aren't causing the population aging. Aside from that there's the general problems you always have with prohibition, people will use other substances on the black market, many of which will be worse.
- kirrent 10y agoWhile it's technically true I've always hated this argument. Yes, smokers are without doubt cheaper for the healthcare system because they die earlier and faster. It's completely missing the point though, because the entire reason we have our healthcare system is to provide a long and high quality life for the population. Someone dying earlier may be cheaper, but it's also a failure.
- flukus 10y agoIt's not a failure of the health system though. Not everyone wants to optimize their life for living longer.
- brokenmachine 10y ago> Not everyone wants to optimize their life for living longer. It would be real nice if they would refrain from optimizing the lives of everyone around them for not living longer as well.
- Trundle 10y agoThe entire reason we have our healthcare system is so that a long and high quality life is an option for the population. It seems pretty apparent to me that most people aren't optimising for either though. No reason to get paternalistic with it.
- dbaupp 10y agoSmoking imposes one person's choice on many others, in terms of length and quality of life, via the negative effects of passive smoking (and also just day-to-day---I personally hate having to suffer through someone's acrid fumes). If people smoked without releasing the byproducts into the air everyone else breathes, this argument would make more sense. But even then, there's massive money and expertise behind advertising (etc.) for getting people hooked, against what may be their "actual" preferences.
- flukus 10y agoEveryone releases stuff into the air that effects others, from perfume to car exhaust to barbecues. Why is your car exhaust ok but not my cigarette smoke?
- grzm 10y agoThere are legal limits placed on exhaust. VW is one recent example of this. If I were to pump exhaust from my car into your home, I'm sure there would be repercussions. I believe there are regulations with respect to perfume as well— yup, there are ADA guidelines in the US[0]. I can imagine cases where barbecues have been considered a nuisance. Found an example of that, too.[1] When looking up the phrase "my rights end where yours begin", I came across the much more colorful "Your liberty to swing your fist ends just where my nose begins". I don't think the freedom to emit noisome or noxious fumes is quite as unlimited as implied by your comment. [0]: https://www.laborlawcenter.com/education-center/new-ada-guidelines-for-fragrance-sensitivity/ https://www.laborlawcenter.com/education-center/new-ada-guid... [1]: http://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/2015/07/27/florida-county-tells-resident-to-keep-barbecue-smoke-in-his-own-yard.html http://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/2015/07/27/florida-county-... (includes autoplay video, sorry)
- vacri 10y agoWell, thank god our friends and relatives are dying young so I can save a bob or two in tax!
- Asooka 10y agoI like that line of thinking. Can't we make it more efficient though? Like, have a live grenade in the filter of every 1% of cigarettes to blow off the smoker's head. Есть человек — есть проблема, нет человека — нет проблемы.
- brokenmachine 10y agoHad to google translate your little saying there. There are people - there is a problem, there are no people - no problem I like the idea.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- phjesusthatguy3 10y ago>It certainly is a regressive tax, but is it really punishing someone if you make it more expensive to legally purchase something that only damages or kills them, is highly addictive and that only places an overall burden on society? Yes.
- chris_wot 10y agoThat's a very short and unconvincing argument. Do feel free to expand on it!
- tmnvix 10y ago> [smoking] places an overall burden on society Are you sure about that?
- chris_wot 10y agoI am sure. Smoking tobacco is recognised as one of the largest preventable causes of death and disease in Australia. Each year, smoking kills an estimated 15,000 Australians and costs Australia $31.5 billion in social (including health) and economic costs. The Australian Government and state and territory governments, through the Council of Australian Governments, have committed by 2018, to reduce the national adult daily smoking rate to 10% and halve the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander adult daily smoking rate (from 47% in 2008). http://www.health.gov.au/tobacco http://www.health.gov.au/tobacco
- gkya 10y agoI am. I've had to sit in smoke-filled cafes (nearly all were so) and to take busses and taxis filled with smokers. I have had to passively smoke in billions of public places and there's no opt-out from that. I'm so glad that in my country, Turkey, a smoking ban in public interior spaces is in effect, and I think that's what really reduces the number of smokers along with people learning how harmful it is. I'm not so keen about the effect of raised prices though.
- tomjen3 10y ago>with an extensive quit smoking program Do they hand out or heavily encourage ecigs? Are those cheap in general and permitted to be used everywhere on public property? Because if so I accept your agreement, because it is clearly not about punishing people for enjoying something, but if not, then I assume the people who run it are just another bunch of statists out to kill as much fun as they can.
- ekimekim 10y agoCan't speak to ecigs in particular, but most of the ads I've seen push addiction-combating substitutes like nicotine patches.
- spangry 10y agoIt's a pity you're being downvoted, because your first paragraph is factually correct. I guess people don't want to hear it if it conflicts with their (mistaken) preconceptions.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoIt's been highly effective at lowering the smoking rate. In a country with taxpayer funded healthcare.
- spangry 10y agoCitation? If you're talking about Australia btw (where I live), I'd suggest that's a highly debatable proposition.
- flukus 10y agoThe smoking rate has dropped down to nearly single digits. They exact cause is impossible to tell.
- vacri 10y agoSmoking has been gradually phased out here over the course of 30 years. It used to be that around 40% of adults smoked, and now it's down to 10-12%. If you think that smoking rates haven't changed significantly here over the past few decades, you're either very young or very blinkered. Or just listen to smokers complaining how they're a dying breed (works on two levels, that one), or how you can't just ask anyone for a light anymore as fewer people carry lighters, and how bumming a cigarette off a stranger is no longer commonplace now that cigs are over a buck each.
- spangry 10y agoI'm not questioning that smoking rates have dropped. That's absolutely true, and an easily verifiable fact. What I'm questioning is the assertion that higher taxes on cigarettes have been the primary cause of this reduction in the smoking rate. It's important that we carefully account for all the factors at play and arrive at a considered answer. If we do this, we then know the most effective way to combat, and hopefully one day, eliminate, smoking. It really kills me that there seems to be a lot of lazy thinking around this subject. It has for a number of years, in fact. I hope this isn't taken as an 'appeal to authority' argument, but I'm an economist who has worked in tax policy for a number of years, during which time I actually advised a couple of Australian Prime Ministers and their Cabinets on excise tax. I'm not trying to be a contrarian here. If people know what is and is not effective, then they are in a better position to pressure their elected representatives to take effective measures to combat smoking.
- tajen 10y agoEvery tax punishes the poor first, but what's the other solution: Let the cigarette be affordable for the poor? According to the theory that poor people make bad life choices[1], they'll smoke anyway; so the discussion is only whether the higher, middle and smart-lower classes would be deterred by taxes on toxic products, and the answer is yes, so let's not enter into a fallacy about the poor people to deter us from saving the rest of the people. [1] It's a theory I don't agree with – I think they're as responsible as us and taxes on cigarettes still deter them from smoking.
- MK999 10y agoSo is lotto. Rich people mostly don't smoke or play state lottery.
- elementalest 10y agoI think its not just the tax, but the combination of plain packaging (strong imagery) and the laws regarding where people can smoke. It makes it harder for people to continue to smoke, providing motivation to quit. However, I think its more about providing a strong deterrent for potential new smokers.
- brokenmachine 10y ago> regressive tax that mostly punishes the poor for smoking "The poor" need to reevaluate their priorities if smoking is their choice for spending their limited resources. How else should activities that are bad for society be discouraged? It's interesting that the rich are much more likely to choose not to smoke even though they are the ones who can actually afford it. I'm not sure what that means but it's interesting to me. Smoking rates go down by level of education but is that cause or correlation? What makes poor people want to smoke more than rich? > If cost of living issues were really their number one priority then these sin taxes would be the first to go. Not sure about this. Cost of living IMO is about affordable housing, food and transport. You know, the actual essentials, not non-essential "luxuries" such as poisonous addictions.