4 ms·
founder here — I'll be checking in on the thread in case folks have questions!
by gnicholas 10y ago
founder here — I'll be checking in on the thread in case folks have questions!
- grok2 10y agoHow do you determine what's across the aisle for any given X?
- gnicholas 10y agoGood question. There are two basic approaches: (1) have a set ranking of sites, and decide what's "center"; or (2) determine the center based on what the person's preference is (either stated, or based on answers to questions). For now, we're starting out with option 1. We would love to build something more complex, like option 2, so that it's personalized for each user. Our rating data comes from various reputable sources, including public polling, and some crowdsourcing (via our kickstarter backers).
- beaconstudios 10y agoit'd be interesting to see what ends up being the center based on public opinion. My understanding was always that the "fixed center" (as opposed to the Overton window) of politics was renaissance/classical liberalism, as both the left and the right draw many stances from varying interpretations of it. I'd be open to seeing how my opinion differs from others who have different stances.
- tropo 10y agoThe example puts Fox at one extreme. Uh, might this be your own filter bubble? Not too long ago, there was a study posted here with statistics-derived positioning that showed Fox being barely right of center. (BTW, can anybody dig that study up?) FWIW you're missing Drudge Report, Breitbart, Stormfront, The Daily Stormer, The Daily Caller, /r/The_Donald You had more on the other side, but Mother Jones was notably missing.
- gnicholas 10y agoThe video is just a demo. There will be news to the right of Fox News, don't worry. Also note that the farthest left source shown is HuffPo. We'll likely include farther left sources also, like Occupy Democrats. Ultimately, the list of sources will be driven by the crowdsourced voting. There is also voting on partisanship ratings. Thanks for pointing out how this could come across though. We certainly don't want to turn anyone off, even inadvertently.
- ouid 10y agoThe center is defined constructively as "news presented in order of significance and without providing commentary". These are objective metrics, though they are very hard to calculate. And while any particular ranking is likely to be subjective, the standard is not.
- tropo 10y agoThe news is infinite though. Inconvenient news could be left out, and that would still meet your standard. There is also the matter of the English language having numerous ways to express the same thing. Choice of words matters, even if the cold facts don't change. Example: did the cars collide, crash, hit each other, smash into each other, or have an accident? Was the child spanked, swatted, hit, whacked, struck, or paddled?
- ouid 10y agoI said ordered by significance. If something is left out of my ideally objective news outlet, then it was, by construction, less significant than the things that were included. To address your second point, connotation is objectively a part of meaning. I did not merely require that this ideally objective news source SEEM objective. It has to actually be objective. Frankly, the argument you made was that the existence of "farther right wing" media pushed fox towards the center. All I have to do is demonstrate that there exists an objective presentation of newsworthy facts, even if only in an abstract sense, and then show that fox has not changed its position relative to itself, over time, to show that your argument is false. Centered does not mean average, when it comes to reporting, it means objective.