6 ms·
I'm not sure Hillary Clinton is a good stand in for "liberals" in this argument, for the same reason (if not to the same extent) that I think Trump wouldn't be
by kbenson 10y ago
I'm not sure Hillary Clinton is a good stand in for "liberals" in this argument, for the same reason (if not to the same extent) that I think Trump wouldn't be a good stand in for "conservatives".
To clarify, your point may be entirely correct, I just don't think using Hillary Clinton advances your argument usefully.
- btilly 10y agoWell, think on this. The last President to shrink the NSA, CIA, etc was Jimmy Carter. Every other one increased it. Reagan got them into arms deals with Iran. Bush Sr, former CIA director, was a staunch ally. Bill Clinton expanded ECHELON, tried to regulate cryptography (remember the Clipper chip?), Bush Jr passed the Patriot Act, Obama expanded the NSA and in pursuit of leakers filed more acts under the Espionage Act than all previous presidents combined. At what point can we conclude that the problem is bipartisan? Of all prominent nominees this time around, only Bernie Sanders, Rand Paul and Ted Cruz said anything against the continued expansion of the surveillance state. Of all prominent nominees for 2012, only Ron Paul spoke out against the surveillance state. For 2008, only Kucinich and Ron Paul spoke out against the surveillance state. If Hillary Clinton were an isolated example, then your point would be good. But she is not. She squarely represents the political mainstream.
- kbenson 10y agoI'm merely pointing out that in a discussion about liberals and conservatives, picking one person to represent the liberal point of view and then arguing against that person instead of addressing goals of the party in general is not a constructive way to proceed.
- boomboomsubban 10y ago>The last President to shrink the NSA, CIA, etc was Jimmy Carter. Every other one increased it. And why was Carter able to shrink them? Because Nixon was caught using them to gain political power. The problem is beyond partisan politics. You either support the intelligence agencies, or you don't get elected. Simple as that.
- WillyOnWheels 10y agoCarter was able to shrink the intelligence budget because the 1975-1976 Church Committee hearings publicized bad practices by US intelligence agencies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Committee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Committee
- boomboomsubban 10y agoThe Church Committee was a response to things that came out during the Watergate scandal, and I find it hard to believe that the public cared more about that than the things that than the Watergate scandal itself.
- btilly 10y agoAnd the result is that Reagan-Bush were strongly supported by the intelligence agencies. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/October_Surprise_conspiracy_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/October_Surprise_conspiracy_th... for a conspiracy theory about how far that support might have gone. (I personally put that theory in the range, "quite plausible, but unproven".)
- CWuestefeld 10y agoThe last President to shrink the NSA, CIA, etc was Jimmy Carter. It was also under the Carter administration - and under Democratic majorities in both the House and Senate - that the FISA Act was passed, which is what eventually led to all this secret surveillance.
- btilly 10y agoThe FISA Act replaced previous warrantless actions, so bad as it is it was still an improvement on the status quo.
- kbenson 10y ago> the FISA Act was passed, which is what eventually led to all this secret surveillance. That's like saying speed limits led to to the problem of people driving fast. FISA was a set of limits put in place because the surveillance was already happening. Oversight where there was none prior.
- dragonwriter 10y agoNo, the FISA Act restricted warrantless domestic surveillance by criminalizing it in response to abuses, largely by the Nixon Administration, before there was any statute law addressing the issue. What legally opened the door for subsequent warrantless surveillance was the passage of the FISA Amendments Act of 2008 which loosened the FISA restrictions to make legal what the Bush Administration had already been doing.
- masonic 10y agothe FISA Amendments Act of 2008 In 2008, Democrats controlled both houses of Congress.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> In 2008, Democrats controlled both houses of Congress. And neither of the major US parties (and especially not the Democratic Party, whose major factions include both a center-right faction and a moderate left faction) are unified cohesive parties with strong discipline as you might find in a multiparty parliamentary system; the FISA Amendments Act passed with every Republican that voted in either house (except one in the House) and a minority of Democrats on each house supporting it, and the majority of Democrats in each house opposing it.
- aero142 10y agoShe just won the popular vote by a large margin with a D next to her name. She has a ridiculous amount of evidence to show that she is the core of the Democratic party and the only person I had as an alternative to Trump to vote for. She isn't a stand in for every wing of liberalism in the US, but she is definitely the center of the liberal wing with any real influence.
- kbenson 10y ago> She just won the popular vote by a large margin with a D next to her name. So? It's not like we have an unlimited pool of candidates of every possible variation such that we can choose the one that best averages all the views of a party. Consider that we were fairly closet to having Bernie Sanders and not Hillary Clinton be the person in that position. That should illustrate how ridiculous it is to use a single person to stand in for the entire group. > She ... the only person I had as an alternative to Trump to vote for. That's irrelevant. There was a discussion about liberalism and conservatism, and someone replied with criticisms about Hillary Clinton instead of liberals in general or liberalism (note this wasn't about Democrats and Republicans, so that D is a red herring). Even if Hillary were more representative of the norm in all mainstream liberal ideas, using her specifically would not be appropriate. As it is, she diverges fairly heavily from traditional liberal ideas in some aspects, which makes it even more of a bad idea.