3 ms·
That's easy to say for someone with a good income. For a lot of people wages go down while cost of living goes up.
by maxxxxx 10y ago
That's easy to say for someone with a good income. For a lot of people wages go down while cost of living goes up.
- ryanworl 10y agoThat's not what I'm getting at. I'm referring to technology specifically. Cost of living is dictated predominantly by the cost of housing, healthcare, education, and food. Food cost as a % of income has decreased significantly since 1960 according to the USDA [1]. Technology and globalization have impacted food a lot. Education, and housing? Not nearly as much. Healthcare is more complicated, and I'm not an expert, so I'll refrain from speculating there. One might argue globalization has hurt people, but so far, technology seems to be making just about everything it touches cheaper for everyone. [1] https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery/chart-detail/?chartId=76967 https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery...
- dukeluke 10y agoThe problem is that the benefits of globalization are offset by the centralization of the remaining jobs, and is adding to the inequality seen in America. There are some parts of the country doing fantastic, but a lot of the Midwest is seeing lower wages, fewer jobs, and a lower quality of life.
- kmicklas 10y agoThat's largely a false narrative.
- dukeluke 10y agoWhat do you mean by this? What did I say that was false?
- kmicklas 10y agoYou're right that certain parts of the country have been hit hard by automation and globalization but the idea that the hard hit people are the Trump voters is not particularly true.
- dukeluke 10y agoFrom what I've read, you are wrong. Of course there are a lot of factors that go into an election, but here's the site that tells me it's definitely a factor: https://econsnapshot.com/2016/11/14/how-trump-won/amp/ https://econsnapshot.com/2016/11/14/how-trump-won/amp/ In the future, if you could provide a source for your argument, it could give more substantive discussion.
- mdorazio 10y agoYes, but why is it making things cheaper where it touches? Usually it's because it allows production with fewer people or by people with lower wages than before. Thus things get cheaper because some subset of people lose jobs or wages. That's fine as long as those people are able to find new jobs or supplemental income sources (many do), but I think the point here is that it's not a universal benefit. I have to agree with the parent post here - for some portion of people, technology has led to lower wages while cost of living decreases (food, products, etc.) are offset by increases in things you need to lift yourself up (healthcare, education, housing).
- antisthenes 10y ago> Cost of living is dictated predominantly by the cost of housing, healthcare, education, and food. > so far, technology seems to be making just about everything it touches cheaper for everyone. You say this, but only provide a source for 1 out of 4 key indicators of cost of living. Can you provide the same evidence towards housing, healthcare and education becoming significantly cheaper as a % of a budget of an average household? Otherwise that statement is just incorrect.
- ryanworl 10y agoI fully agree that there are multiple forces at work here and globalization and technology are not a universal benefit to the western poor and middle-income. I just wanted to expose something commonly left out of these discussions, which is that technology is generally deflationary. More technology in the areas of healthcare, education, and housing might be the solution, not the problem.
- ryanworl 10y ago@antisthenes: I did not say technology has made housing, education, or healthcare cheaper. Please read what I said again.
- koolba 10y ago> That's easy to say for someone with a good income. For a lot of people wages go down while cost of living goes up. Bullshit. Technology brings down the cost of living by making the supply side more efficient. What goes up is the cost of the way you'd like to live as you have more options to choose from. Obviously there's disruptions along the way (ex: automobiles lessen demand for horse breeders) but when capitalism closes a door it opens a window (ex: mechanics).
- IslaDeEncanta 10y agoYou have no idea if you think technology magically brings down prices. Tell that to the 100 million people living in/near poverty in the USA alone. The "efficiency" increases in recent years have more often than not been various ways of cutting labor costs. It doesn't matter if things are cheaper in a nominal sense if your ability to earn a living is eroded.
- koolba 10y ago> You have no idea if you think technology magically brings down prices. Tell that to the 100 million people living in/near poverty in the USA alone. I suggest you go do some basic math on the cost of producing consumer staples like rice, beans, milk, and meat. Technology has brought down the cost of all of them. Similarly, efficiency gains in MPG and durability improvements have lowered the price of owning and maintaining a vehicle. Uber, Lyft, and other ride sharing apps have lowered the price of it even further to remove the capital outlay. > The "efficiency" increases in recent years have more often than not been various ways of cutting labor costs. Which is bad because why exactly? Is the purpose of the corporate sector to produce goods and services or to provide a place for people to go? > It doesn't matter if things are cheaper in a nominal sense if your ability to earn a living is eroded. Sure it is. That's the definition of makes things more efficient: being able to be produced more cheaply
- tabeth 10y agoYou make fair points, however the cost of living is dictated primarily by: transportation, education, housing and health costs. Has technology made these significantly cheaper for someone in poverty?