3 ms·
> Think back to those old school Nokias with mechanical flips and switches that felt so satisfying to just open and close. This speaks to something I find myse
by smacktoward 10y ago
> Think back to those old school Nokias with mechanical flips and switches that felt so satisfying to just open and close.
This speaks to something I find myself missing more and more: tactile user interfaces.
Think of an old flip phone. It starts ringing. How do you answer the call? You snap the phone open. How do you hang up? Snap it closed.
That is a really beautifully usable interface! It's made up entirely of actions you can do with your eyes closed. Those actions are big and broad, not subtle at all, so they don't require much of your attention. They map directly to our intuitive understanding of how things work (open = in use, closed = not in use). You can teach them to someone without using a single word.
Now we've replaced that (and everything else) with a new interface: tapping at a smooth sheet of glass. And that interface has none of the appealing qualities the old flip phone did: it's fiddly and fussy, you have to give it your full attention to avoid hitting the wrong button, it requires learning a bunch of new metaphors, and so forth. Technologically it's much more advanced, but none of that technology actually goes towards making the user's life easier.
We replaced a pickup truck with a moon rocket. The moon rocket may be a marvel, but which would you rather use to haul your groceries home?
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoTake a look at the old Star Trek (TOS) shows. Bunch of blinking lights and buttons. Seems idiotic, facile. But why wouldn't the goal of controlling a starship be best put into physical buttons with lighted indicators? The physicality of the interface limits the complexity of the system. The physical movements of interacting with the interface is something that can be taught, observed, and coached. One look at a bridge full of panels could tell an experienced eye the entire state of the system, including what people were currently working on. These are all seismically important improvements over the same bridge with 15 officers staring at their smart phone. The old 60s TV set designers got it right, though probably by accident. :) I really believe with modern interface design we've went down a bit of a rat hole here.
- snarf21 10y agoI really really miss the Blackberry keyboard, but not a lot of other things about BB. :(
- kej 10y agoOne of the best phones I ever had was the Samsung SCH-i760 [1]. It had Windows Mobile with a touch screen and a stylus that expanded out of the side, but also had a physical number pad and a slide out keyboard. All the benefits of a smartphone, but you could also answer, hang up, and dial without looking at it. I'd buy an Android phone in that form factor in a heartbeat. [1] http://www.phonearena.com/phones/Samsung-SCH-i760_id1897 http://www.phonearena.com/phones/Samsung-SCH-i760_id1897
- smacktoward 10y agoI had similar feelings about my Palm Pre, though they missed a trick on that one by not letting you pick up and disconnect from calls by sliding the keyboard open and closed. That seemed like such a natural extension of the flip-phone paradigm that I was amazed they didn't go for it.