3 ms·
First, there is an issue if an organization like a school or workplace wants to prevent the viewing of pornography. If wikipedia hosts pornography, it risks be
by jessriedel 17y ago
First, there is an issue if an organization like a school or workplace wants to prevent the viewing of pornography. If wikipedia hosts pornography, it risks being blocked in places where it belongs.
Second, there is the question of child pornography, which has been alleged.
Third, your belief that "As long as adults respond appropriately to the potentially misleading information that porn has exposed kids to, any harms that is done is prevented" is not universally shared, so it isn't surprising that some people will feel differently.
For all of these issues, one needs to ask oneself if the benefit from hosting a certain image is worth the drawbacks. Some images simply have no academic value.
- jarek 17y agoWikipedia hosts depictions of Muhammad, with which it risks getting blocked in entire countries. Strictly speaking they are not necessary in the articles, not the least because they're probably not historically accurate. Do you think they remove them?
- jessriedel 17y agoNecessary is not the same as having academic value. I think depictions of Muhammad have significant academic value. Your point is a good one, though. I'd have to think about this more to come up with a good general principle. (I just don't think that principle is "allow all possible data to be stored on wikipedia/wikicommons".)