4 ms·
I despise Trump, but I don't think it's it's acceptable for a civil servant to insert themselves into the news. If you're getting an unlawful or unethical order
by Spooky23 10y ago
I despise Trump, but I don't think it's it's acceptable for a civil servant to insert themselves into the news. If you're getting an unlawful or unethical order, you follow the process, suck it up or resign in protest.
By going rogue and making yourself the story, you're attacking the office of the president. It's a bad idea, bad precedent and will have bad outcomes.
- hprotagonist 10y agoBollocks. Presidents are not above the law; most of them don't need to have their nose rubbed in the carpet in order to learn that. It is eminently clear that the muslim ban executive order was drafted, written, and released without any of the normal communication, forewarning, or legal reviews. The AG is 100% within their duties to the nation and the constitution to say that they will not enforce something of that nature.
- TenOhms 10y agoDid Obama, Clinton, or Bush have an AG that willfully showed insubordination and encouraged it to their subordinates? I'm surprised her action didn't get more news coverage, well not really.
- hprotagonist 10y agoDid any of the three of them dash off a quick little EO with no warning or legal counsel? And it's not insubordination to refuse to do something that you, the head lawyer for an entire nation, find to be illegal. It's doing your damn job.
- mikelevins 10y agoIn March of 2004 John Ashcroft's Justice Department determined that the Bush Administration's Stellar Wind surveillance program was illegal. While Ashcroft was in the hospital being treated for acute pancreatitis, President Bush sent White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales and Chief of Staff Andrew Card to tell Ashcroft to sign a document overturning his department's ruling. He refused. He remained Attorney General until February 3rd, 2005, when he resigned the office.
- yes_or_gnome 10y agoThe Acting AG at that time? The current FBI director, James Comey. Truth is stranger than fiction.
- Spooky23 10y agoIt's not your place as an appointed official in government to grandstand and get your picture in the news. You are not an elected official, you're there to represent the government. Unfortunately, the conversion of politics to reality tv has affected everyone. You resign. That's ultimately a greater statement anyway.
- wavefunction 10y agoDetermining whether or not to defend an indefensible law is also purview of the office, and a privilege and function of the position. Considering that she was well within her rights and duties of office, it would be _highly_ irresponsible to leave her key position vacant, especially at this time of so much induced chaos.
- Spooky23 10y agoIf that was the case, mouthing off and getting her picture pasted everywhere was an irresponsible act vs an orderly resignation.
- cavisne 10y agoFactually, it did have legal review, as she called out in her own letter https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C3dOVzFXAAIGOlW.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C3dOVzFXAAIGOlW.jpg It's obvious this was a stunt and she fully expected to be fired.
- vixen99 10y agohttps://sethfrantzman.com/2017/01/28/obamas-administration-made-the-muslim-ban-possible-and-the-media-wont-tell-you/ https://sethfrantzman.com/2017/01/28/obamas-administration-m... 'Obama’s administration made the “Muslim ban” possible and the media won’t tell you'
- ssalazar 10y agoThe Nuremberg defense. Classic.
- Spooky23 10y agoNo. The Nuremberg defense is to sit there and do something unethical justifying your continued employment. The ethical course is to resign.
- Retra 10y agoIf the law is illegal, then everyone in that position would have to resign, which would make the resignation pointless. Someone shouldn't have to fall on their sword in order to do the right thing. That way leads to dictators surrounded by spineless yes-men.
- Spooky23 10y agoActually, you do need to fall on your sword in some circumstances. The point of a Nuremberg defense is that you were compelled to do something immoral or illegal by orders of a superior officer or other official. Since senior DOJ lawyers are not conscripted soldiers. Resignation, including mass resignation is the appropriate response. Dictators get surrounded by "spineless yes-men" when people place paying the mortgage above their professional and ethical duty.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mordant 10y agoConsidering that the Nuremberg Trials were a clear-cut case of 'victor's justice', this holds no water with me.
- Spooky23 10y ago-5? Wow the groupthink is amazing here.
- rantanplan 10y agoThat's only one of the possible reasons. Now, have another guess :)