3 ms·
>> The story isn't really about "higher education" in the traditional meaning. It's about taking the blue-collar apprenticeship & training model and calling _th
by phkahler 10y ago
>> The story isn't really about "higher education" in the traditional meaning. It's about taking the blue-collar apprenticeship & training model and calling _that_ a "college degree".
When I was in high school, we had vocational classes. I took electronics, others took small engine repair, welding, or drafting. Hands on classes that in some cases require applied math. I think these are mostly gone in the US today with everyone demanding higher achievement is pure STEM classes. I'm not sure what the "T" for technology is in high school, but I fear people may thing it means the ability to use Word and PowerPoint.
- AtheistOfFail 10y ago> people may thing it means the ability to use Word and PowerPoint. That's what it means these days... as someone who went through the "Advanced Technology" courses in high school... I learned Pivot Tables in Excel... as opposed to programming or something else.
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoThe loss of those classes bothers me. My 10th grader just finished a class in Sheet Metal Fabrication and loved it. He's now taking Welding and plans to do Electronics next year. He signed up for sewing, but it was cancelled due to lack of interest. I can't remember the last time he was that interested in anything at school What's his motivation? He wanted to make costumes for ComicCon and accidentally found something he really enjoys doing. These classes are increasingly rare. Our school district is primarily rural kids, and skills like the above are obviously useful on farms. But the reality is that pushing everyone to college ignores that there are many very smart kids out there who have no interest in college-level academics, or will simply not thrive in that environment. However, they may be fantastic machinists, CAD technicians, electricians, etc.
- granos 10y agoBuy him a sewing machine (assuming you don't have one) and some supplies. There are tons of videos online to teach technique, and it isn't terribly expensive.
- Arizhel 10y agoCollege-bound kids should be taking those classes too. I saw the same thing when I was in high school: they treated things like auto shop as things that college-bound kids shouldn't be doing. So you wind up with college kids who have absolutely no hands-on ability and no understanding of the machines that enable their lives, and then these kids go into engineering school and have no idea how to actually build things that really work. A machinist should not know more about metals properties and how to make things out of metal than a mechanical engineer. The machinist should know more about the particulars of operating a particular machine tool, since he uses it every day, but the mechanical engineer should know more about how to actually make physical things that work, and not just theory. So a class in machining, IMO, is absolutely essential for a ME major. Same thing for EEs and electricians; if a EE can't use hands-on skills to troubleshoot his design, he's a failure of a EE.
- gaius 10y agoI have a degree in Mech Eng from an "elite" college in the UK, and welding, machining etc were required courses. How can you design something without understanding how it will be fabricated or maintained?
- jdcarter 10y agoAgreed, I loved metal shop in junior high. Neither my family nor friends had a shop where I could learn skills like casting and welding. However, rather than modernizing these shops with CNC mills and 3D printers (for example), schools seem to just be shutting them down instead. On the plus side, the cost of doing these things at home has been dropping. My 10 y/o daughter gets to play/learn/experiment with all kinds of stuff that I could hardly touch at her age. Arduinos and modern LEDs make for awesome electronics projects that wow her classmates, but are still cheap enough that she can smoke a part now and then. Fabrication costs are dropping thanks to 3D printers, opening a world that used to require a mill/lathe/etc. to get into. Sewing remains a low-cost hobby that lets you build very cool stuff (and for boys, too!). Of course, it still requires a nerdy family with disposable income to provide this kind of workshop for kids. I've done a lot of projects with my daughter and her friends. For more kids to have that kind of opportunity, however, the schools are really the best place for it.
- germinalphrase 10y agoI used to teach at a high school in rural Wisconsin. The vocational classes you mention are still offered with good connections/support from the local manufacturing industry. This may not be as true as it once was, but they're still alive, kicking, and well attended.