5 ms·
I think one good criterion (among others) for deciding in what country to hold a conference is the number of countries whose citizen can enter without visa. The
by FabHK 10y ago
I think one good criterion (among others) for deciding in what country to hold a conference is the number of countries whose citizen can enter without visa. There's a list on Wikipedia that you can sort by that criterion [1].
For the USA, it's 42 (what else). Canada, 52. For Schengen area (most of EU), 92. Hong Kong, 148, Indonesia, Cambodia even more. China only 12.
So, South East Asia or Europe seem reasonable on that score.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Travel_visa#Visa_policies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Travel_visa#Visa_policies
- alistairSH 10y agoBe careful with those numbers. While they are likely accurate for simply attending a conference, they might not be for presenting at a conference (that often changes the reason for the visit from "education" to "paid work" which can impact the need for a visa). That said, Schengen area is probably still easier than the US for attending AND presenting.
- delinka 10y agoI'm thinking if I were organizing a conference outside my country of residence, I'd keep payment arrangements for speakers & paid guests outside the conference country, and instruct speakers on The Right Things To Say on visiting the country.
- alistairSH 10y agoEek. I would never counsel a somebody to lie at the border. That's a recipe for trouble. My understanding is legal advice is usually along the lines of "tell the truth in as few words as possible."
- delinka 10y agoIf you're assuming that I'd espouse lying, how are the "lies of omission" that you imply any different? The Right Thing To Say does not involve lying. It involves being careful; not oversharing. "Tell the truth in as few words as possible." Exactly this. No need to ramble on about your detailed itinerary. For example: You're here for "education." Will you be the teacher or the learner? You'll be sharing your experience in programming just as you will listen to others sharing the same. It's a "conference" - we will confer on the topic of the event.
- wil421 10y agoIt wouldn't be a lie of omission if you said "I'm a speaker at a technology conference". Then let them ask you other questions if they want more information. If you said "I'm a well paid speaker headlining DefCon haking conference" or something similar, you'd probably get a different response. DefCon is just an example that could raise an eyebrow.
- alistairSH 10y agoAlongside your comment about keeping payment outside the country, I construed your comment to mean you would attempt to hide the fact that the speakers are paid, and avoid the question of work visas completely.
- deerpig 10y agoAs an American citizen living in Cambodia -- book events here. It's cheaper and the conference facilities are getting better every year. It's time for Americans to stop thinking all roads lead to them.
- virmundi 10y agoI'd like Americans to think all road lead to them because we offer the best destination. Presently we think all roads lead to the US because they do, but we've forgotten why. We think that is just the way of the world. We need to pursue the solid, innovative research in all fields and disseminate that accordingly.
- mjolk 10y agoYou're speaking as if getting to Cambodia is the same as a quick/cheap flight for most people, especially those who use English as a lingua franca. You're suggesting a very unrealistic alternative to NYC, Seattle, or Austin. Americans don't think that "all roads lead to them", but America is a hugely important country with a large number of its population working in the tech field and "convenient to get to" is impossible to underestimate as a priority when organizing a conference.
- Spooky23 10y agoThe best criterion is "where are the customers"? The probability of most US based people attending an international conference is dramatically lower.
- FabHK 10y agoSure, I was thinking international conferences. More domestically oriented ones do domestically, obviously, unless the purpose is more of a funded vacation.
- ryandamm 10y agoSelf-centered American here, but wouldn't it make sense to weight it by population, or even population of likely attendees? Not clear why, say, Suriname (to pick a country out of a hat) should rank equally with Japan. That said, I think the point of your post (and the original post) is just to call out how ridiculous and sad the US's sudden policy swerve is. I hate how often the US compares unfavorably with the rest of the developed world on all sorts of indices; we're so strange. Strangely illiberal, even before November. (I mean 'illiberal' in the political theory sense of the word, not left/right political sense of the word.)
- Silhouette 10y agoThat said, I think the point of your post (and the original post) is just to call out how ridiculous and sad the US's sudden policy swerve is. One of the most alarming things about this whole issue is that it's taken this long for "normal people" to realise something is wrong and do something about it. We're seeing mass protests now, when large numbers of people are literally being held in handcuffs for extended periods despite obviously doing nothing wrong. However, it's not as if border security at the US (and, to be fair, here in the UK and in various other countries) hadn't completely lost the plot already before Trump arrived. Then again, I have long said things would have to get worse before they got better. Let's hope that at least we have now reached that point and ordinary people start questioning the whole way we look at security again.
- FabHK 10y ago> wouldn't it make sense to weight it by population, or even population of likely attendees? You're right, of course. > the point of your post (and the original post) is just to call out how ridiculous and sad the US's sudden policy swerve is. Yes, getting visa can be a time-consuming, expensive, even humiliating hassle - I've seen it with * friends (one friend was planning to visit the USA for the first time this Christmas, was twice denied visa (no reasons provided), so did not go), * colleagues (a colleague working in Hong Kong could not get permission for his wife to join him there), and * myself (and I travel on a German passport, which is the best in that regard: 177 countries visa free/visa on arrival). So, I genuinely think that among the things to consider (among others) when planning an international conference is easy entry for attendees. However, the sad thing is that it's not a sudden policy swerve. The USA has had a rather restrictive visa policy for decades. It has obviously historically been wide open, but increasing suspicion of economic migrants, and then after 9/11 increasing suspicion of terrorists seems to have made it more and more defensive of the borders. I personally find US CBP (custom and border protection) among the potentially least pleasant (and I've been to 100+ countries). ("Potentially" because you can be lucky and have a friendly reception and no problems at all, but you sure can have grumpy questions and more serious problems.) The Recurse Center, a great programming retreat in NY, used to be called Hacker School. With the old name, attendees regularly had trouble with CBP (the dreaded secondary inspection), and I seem to recall that some have been denied entry. I believe that was one of the factors behind the name change. So, yes, your perceptive observation that this is another index on which the US compares less favourably to the rest of the developed world as sometimes assumed also contributed to the post. Recent events have made it even worse - and I'm glad to see that the resistance is rising :-)
- matt4077 10y agoHaving organised a pretty large student conference in the past, here are some further considerations: - Obviously the specific countries behind those numbers matter. If you're organising a conference on 14th century Flemish literature, the Netherlands will be more important than North Korea - Not all restrictions are created equal. Specifically, the activity I was involved in (University Debating) has a sizeable Israeli community, who would argue that travel restrictions that jews encounter across the muslim world should be considered more harshly than most other travel restrictions, which tend to emanate from a fear of economic migration. - beware self-fulfilling prophecies: If you chose a location that is hard for sub-saharan african nationals to reach because they're underrepresented in your audience, you are also perpetuating that underrepresentation.
- dragonwriter 10y agoSeems to me "proportion of your target community that can attend without a visa" would be a more valid metric than "number of countries from which people can enter without a visa". But even better would be to also factor in the difficulty of getting the necessary visa for others.