5 ms·
If a company can't recruit an immigrant worker on a visa they'll try recruit one of the currently unemployed local developers on the exact same package the immi
by onion2k 10y ago
If a company can't recruit an immigrant worker on a visa they'll try recruit one of the currently unemployed local developers on the exact same package the immigrant would have been on. That has no impact on wages.
If the job required a unique talent that would only have been possible to fill with an exceptionally talented immigrant worker then the job won't be filled, and the company will be consequently less competitive. That will likely drive the wages of their workers down if a different company (in India perhaps) is able to utilize that worker's skills.
For example, imagine the next Jony Ive can't get a visa so he stays in the UK and works for a British company instead.. How would that impact American wages?
- anjc 10y agoWhy would it drive wages down?! It'd be the exact opposite, and is the reason that wages have been stagnant in STEM, and is the reason for the wage collusion scandal. Companies would have to increase their offers to attract talent from other companies. Or they would have to - as used to be the case everywhere - accept that talent is nurtured from within.
- hocuspocus 10y agoIT services aren't STEM. The wage collusion scandal happened at a time where yearly H-1B quotas were typically not met! (Edit: I'm wrong, they were met, but much more slowly than they are today, no lottery needed back then). Today there's roughly 4 times more applications than visas delivered through the lottery, and the wages in tech have never been so high. If you get screwed by your employer within the framework of labor laws, don't blame it on immigration.
- anjc 10y agoWould that not demonstrate the point then? You're saying wages aren't stagnant anymore, occurring at a time when the demand for workers has finally outstripped supply because not enough visas are issued. So don't blame it on immigration now, fine. But if issuances of visas increase then you're back in the <2012 situation of stagnant or decreasing wages due to the availability of cheaper workers. So can you then blame stagnant industry wages on immigration? Displacement of indigenous workers is also a major issue. By the way, I wasn't trying to "blame it on immigration", my ire is solely directed at corporate lobbying for public policy, given that their sole motivation is an increase of private profits regardless of the socioeconomic side-effects. It should not be allowed.
- hocuspocus 10y agoI think it demonstrates there's hardly any correlation between STEM wages and H-1B abuse. I'm all for fewer visas delivered to IT consulting firms, but I don't see not much of an intersection between this issue and stagnating wages in the tech industry. A reform of the H-1 would be nice but it should try to give a chance to small startups as well, not just hand over visas to the handful of companies that pay engineers over $250k. The current lottery is silly but at least it's unfair to everyone equally :)
- threeseed 10y agoNot sure what on earth you're expecting with STEM wages. Across the economy and in most countries wages have been stagnant and STEM is no exception. And don't forget that most IT projects are not mandatory. If wages rise significantly companies will just cut back on projects which means more unemployed talent and hence the wages will drop back. And there is no evidence that talent is better nurtured from within. It is just as beneficial for companies to have outsiders with unique experiences and viewpoints join.
- anjc 10y agoYou'd expect wages to rise when it's in industries with supposed skills shortages, which necessitates major corporations lobbying government for more visas. If wages rose, companies couldn't just uniformly cut back on projects to keep their net profit the same in a hypercompetitive industry. Hence the wage collusion scandal, mentioned above.
- sheepmullet 10y ago> If wages rise significantly companies will just cut back on projects The more likely outcome is companies will adopt more efficient work practices. A slowly rising cost of labor fuels automation and increased value for society.
- UK-AL 10y agoSurely if companies are desperate for developers, there would be very few unemployed developers.
- onion2k 10y agoIf local wages are high then it's possible for companies to be desperate for workers and for there to be high levels of unemployment. For example, if someone adds $50k to the company's bottom line then paying them more than $50k represents a loss. This is actually one of the tech industries biggest challenges - how do you drive the cost of products down to compete in the marketplace when producing software costs so much due to high wages. The simplest answer is to drive wages down by recruiting immigrants. The long term answer is increase the pool of available labor by pushing for children to learn to code at school.
- UK-AL 10y agoThen you offer them 40K and they accept because its better than being unemployed? That's literally how markets work. They go up or down based on demand.
- Chris2048 10y agoWhy assume a specialized job "won't be filled", but a job were "the exact same package the immigrant would have been on" is offered will? I believe H1B visas are currently used to get workers who accept lower-than-average wages; Hence the same jobs offered to non H1B workers at that level won't be attractive.
- onion2k 10y agoH1B visas are generally used for cheap labour. L1 and L2 visas are used for workers with "specialized knowledge" who are necessary because is no local option.
- scarlac 10y agoL1 visa are used for intra-company transfers. They are not freely available to anyone with special knowledge. If the company has a division outside of the US, then you'd need to work there for at least a year before applying for an L1. L2 is for dependents of a L1 holder, like a spouse or child.
- a-non-emu 10y agoH-1B data is public. You can go see what Google, Apple, Amazon et al are paying their H-1B workers. It's no different from what any American worker would get for the same positions.
- Chris2048 10y agoCan you see what hours those workers are working? But in any case: > It's no different from what any American worker would get for the same positions It's what Americans might get if they accepted the positions, but it isn't necessarily what they'd have to offer to get Americans to accept those positions; And if supply fell, but not demand, [make better offers is] what they'd have to do.
- losvedir 10y agoSurely it depends on the particular reforms. As mentioned in the article: > “If firms are using the program for cheap labor, I think it will affect them and they will have to pay workers more,” said Ron Hira, an associate professor at Howard University. “If tech firms are using the program for specialized labor, they may find there are more visas available.” If that were true then wages would likely rise, and your "unique talent" could still be found, possibly even with increase probability, right?
- sheepmullet 10y ago> If the job required a unique talent that would only have been possible to fill with an exceptionally talented immigrant worker then the job won't be filled, Actually wage floors or setting up a bid/auction based system makes it more likely the exceptionally talented worker can get a visa.