2 ms·
There is something to this. Collective expectations are a powerful force. If most of us feel that in the 21st century every child deserves a good education, or
by EGreg 10y ago
There is something to this. Collective expectations are a powerful force. If most of us feel that in the 21st century every child deserves a good education, or healthcare, we will act in a certain way when we see a child not getting it.
That having been said, most Americans on the left and right have an expectation that their country has a great tradition and robust institution for human rights. Conservatives emphasize financial freedom. Liberals emphasize social freedom. Both claim to emphasize freedom of speech, etc.
So the difference is that even if Adams' theory is correct and people "wishing for" Hitler thereby "bring him about", they have also "wished for" a Congress and Judicial branch that care enough about the above rights that they would impeach and charge him with high crimes or treason if he ever violated serious rights.
We can apply this logic to existing phenomena. I am a liberal and see Republican opposition to Obamacare largely as hypocritical partisanship. Millions of Republicans are gleeful if Obamacare leads to growing deductibles, bad availability of good insurance plans in some states, and millions dropping coverage because they can't afford it anymore. Sad right? But, they are doing it out of a sense that at the Obamacare mandate is against the principle of Freedom. While that may be misguided, and their opposition to single payer in Healthcare might look silly alongside their acceptance of it in Public Education, nevertheless look at the motivation. Americans across every major party share a respect for values of Human Liberty and Limited Government. This is a good common ground.
I say that, what as should really preserve is the systsm of checks and balances. Hitler by himself no matter how powerful is nothing without centralization of government and a removal of the opposition. What you should worry about is the 2010 REDMAP gerrymandering and the refusal to vote on supreme court justices nominated by Obama. That is actually a dangerous example of a party stealing power permanently from the people by breaking the rules.
Already a judge in NYC pushed back on the ban. And by pushing the GOP to repeal-and-replace Obamacare ASAP, or refusing to do anything negative to Saudis and Russians, Trump is not actually making the Republicans any more comfortable with him.