3 ms·
Flagging political threads isn't stopping that either - that spillover is what flagging comments and downvotes are already for, and moderators detaching off-top
by krapp 10y ago
Flagging political threads isn't stopping that either - that spillover is what flagging comments and downvotes are already for, and moderators detaching off-topic tangents.
But what hiding stories does accomplish is preventing people who don't want to see that content from being angered by its presence, especially when a topic threatens to overwhelm the site, and otherwise takes up most of the comments feed in a heated discussion, or most of the new topics page in the case of a popular story.
Although a more proactive approach would be to better curate the comments feed. It still seems that high traffic or volatile threads contribute a lot of low quality spillover there, and a lot of low hanging fruit for flamebaiting and drive-by comments.
- grzm 10y agoFlagging political threads isn't stopping that either True. It doesn't stop it. I think it does limit it, to some extent. a more proactive approach would be to better curate the comments feed. Interesting. Do you think the community would bear more aggressive curation?
- krapp 10y ago>Do you think the community would bear more aggressive curation? As it wouldn't affect the rank of the stories themselves, I don't see why not. It might not need human intervention either, just apply a few rules before building the comment page such as not displaying comments from a certain depth (which tend to be tangential) or not displaying downvoted comments, and preferring upvoted comments.
- grzm 10y agoHmmm. I was thinking more along the lines of more aggressively flagging/downvoting. Though I think either would see (some) members complaining about censorship.