3 ms·
Note that all those computers shared the same bus, and so that the complete system wasn't as redundant as hoped as this story[1] retells: "At 12:12 GMT 13 May
by Trombone12 10y ago
Note that all those computers shared the same bus, and so that the complete system wasn't as redundant as hoped as this story[1] retells:
"At 12:12 GMT 13 May 2008, a space shuttle was loading its hypergolic fuel for mission STS-124 when a 3-1 disagreement occurred among its General Purpose Computers (GPC 4 disagreed with the other GPCs). Three seconds later, the split became 2-1-1 (GPC 2 now disagreed with GPC 4 and the other two
GPCs). This required that the launch countdown be stopped.
During the subsequent troubleshooting, the remaining two GPCs disagreed (1-1-1-1 split). This was a complete system disagreement. However, none of the GPCs were faulty. The fault was in the FA 2 Multiplexer Demultiplexer. This fault was a crack in a diode. This crack was perpendicular to the normal current flow and completely through the current path. As a crack opened up, it changed the diode into another type of component ... a capacitor.
Because some of the bits in the signal are smaller than they should have been, some of the GPC receivers could not see these bits. The ability to see these bits depends on the sensitivity of the receiver, which is a function of manufacturing variances, temperature, and its power supply voltage.
From the symptoms, it is apparent that the receiver in GPC 4 was the least sensitive and saw the errors before the other three GPC. This caused GPC 4 to disagree with the other three. Then, as the crack in the diode widened, the bits became shorter to the point where GPC 2 could no longer see these bits; which caused it to disagree with the other GPC. At this point, the set of messages that was received correctly by GPC 4 was different from the set of messages that was correctly received by GPC 2 which was different again from the set of messages that was correctly received by GPC 1 and GPC 3. This process continued until GPC 1 and GPC 3 also disagreed with all the other GPC."
[1] Adapted from https://c3.nasa.gov/dashlink/projects/79/wiki/test_stories_split/ https://c3.nasa.gov/dashlink/projects/79/wiki/test_stories_s...
- hashhar 10y agoIs there a website which collects/links to such anecdotes and surfaces interesting ones? I would to read more such stories.