4 ms·
The Crisis of the Multiverse
- FascinatedBox 10y agoI'm not sure why, but this site is adding several history entries. It's even worse when I try to navigate down using arrow keys.
- jiggliemon 10y agoWas going to gripe about the same thing. Looks like they're injecting history per scroll event.
- samirillian 10y agoNot to mention, this particular article was called out by another HN article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13451310 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13451310 as glorified pseudoscientific clickbait.
- jessriedel 10y agoOn Chrome Android I get a new history entry for every partial step scrolling down the page. Hitting the back button leads to slowly inching back up the page 1 cm at a time.
- jessriedel 10y agoOn Chrome Android I get a new history entry for every partial step scrolling down the page. Hitting the back button leads to slowly inching back up the page 1 cm at a time.
- derrickdirge 10y agoOn mobile safari it completely fills the back button history, making it impossible to actually go back. Pretty egregious UX.
- MattRix 10y agoYeah it's awful, though you can go back if you hold the back button, which will pop up a list of history entries.
- jmiserez 10y agoIf you've scrolled too far, the HN page won't show up anymore even if you hold the back button.
- derrickdirge 10y agoThat list is exactly what I'm talking about. By the time I wanted to go back, that list was completely full of links back to the current page and I had to load HN from my favorites instead.
- nobrains 10y agoThe crisis of the nautil.us website back button
- trav4225 10y agoBackGATE!
- protomikron 10y agoUnbelievable, this fucking modern UI designs. How can you publish a page, where the back button is broken, and just call it a day. It is freaking text and some images. We know how to do that, there is no magic, please do not use technology that breaks basic expectations of users.
- justinpombrio 10y ago> Theoretical and observational evidence suggests that we are living in an enormous, eternally expanding multiverse where the constants of nature vary from place to place. Really? What is this evidence? I didn't see much of it in the article. Also, the "sleeper" argument (at least as presented?) seems to be flawed. To repeat, the argument is this: Suppose you are cryogenically frozen, to be woken up in either 1 year or 100 years, determined by the flip of a coin right after you're frozen. Furthermore, say that the population of the Earth doubles every year, and each year 1% of people undergo this experiment. Now suppose you wake up, and wonder how much time has passed. There are two lines of reasoning: 1. Obviously, the odds are 50/50, since the result was determined by the flip of a coin. 2. Whatever year it is, most of the people waking up from the experiment were frozen last year (when the population of Earth was higher). The article then concludes that "The fact that two logical lines of argument yield contradictory answers tells us that the problem is not well-defined." But they're not contradictory; either may hold depending on what you know. The probability of an event depends on your knowledge. Assuming you remember when you were frozen, then there are two possibilities: "I am John Doe who was frozen in 2020 and woke up in 2021", or "I am John Doe who was frozen in 2020 and woke up in 2120". Thus line of reasoning #1 holds. On the other hand, if you're an experimenter who's greeting people as they wake up, then there are many possibilities: "It's 2120, and this was one of the 70 million people who was frozen in 2020", or "It's 2120, and this was one of the 140 million people who was frozen in 2119". Thus line of reasoning #2 holds, and the person you're greeting was probably frozen last year. No contradiction.
- kordless 10y ago> The probability of an event depends on your knowledge. This is a false statement and hints at the dissonance in the argument made for hard determinism.
- ves 10y agoHow is this statement false at all? Conditioning on sigma-algebras, which are the objects at the base of probability theory and which further function as a reasonable model of "knowledge," is at the heart of how we understand probability today. The experimenter and the subject mentioned by the GP both hold different information and we can model that by constructing different sigma-algebras for each, F_e and F_s respectively. It's not at all absurd to think that P(E | F_e) != P(E | F_s) where E is the event in question. This idea holds in general, as you might imagine. I won't address your latter point but the former is definitely not true.
- nonbel 10y agoThere is some interesting background to Nautilus magazine. It is funded by an organization that has the goal of using scientific methods to prove "spiritual" stuff. Since the "spiritual dimension" is so ill defined and hand-wavy, this requires pseudoscientific methods. I am one who sees a lot of pseudoscience out there these days. Undeniably, the primary funding source is US taxpayers, but this looks like another one. http://www.nature.com/news/2011/110216/full/470323a.html http://www.nature.com/news/2011/110216/full/470323a.html https://www.templeton.org/what-we-fund/grants/nautilus https://www.templeton.org/what-we-fund/grants/nautilus
- woodandsteel 10y agoThe article assumes that string theory has been proven correct. From what I understand, that is very far from being true.
- boomboomsubban 10y agoTheories are never proven correct, they can just predict more experimental results. Assuming they're true is what you do.
- miles7 10y agoMy impression is that, far from being proven correct, it's actually falling out of fashion. Some ideas originating in string theory, such as the AdS/CFT correspondence, are having a heyday though.