6 ms·
I could give Trump supporters some slack before. He'd said some racist and sexist things, but it could arguably be written off as bluster. But now he's put his
by simonh 10y ago
I could give Trump supporters some slack before. He'd said some racist and sexist things, but it could arguably be written off as bluster. But now he's put his bluster into action.
This ban clearly has nothing to do with terrorism, if it did the Muslim country that produces the most terrorists and from which the most terrorist funding comes from - Saudi Arabia - would be on the list. I'm not saying they should be on the list, I think there should be no list, but by not having SA on it the argument for the list existing at all is clearly null and void. It's just for show.
This order is pure racism and religious discrimination. It comes on the aniversary of a ship full of German Jews being turned back from the US. Hundreds of people on that boat went to the gas chambers. This order is tearing apart families. Husbands and Wives with partners and children in the US, who's partners and children are US citizens, with homes in the US, jobs in the US and fully valid visas and green cards are being prevented from joining their families. All they did was take a short trip abroad and now they are barred from entering the country where they and their family live. What are these people supposed to do? This attitude that it's ok to do this to these people just because of their religion or country of origin, that the damage to them doesn't matter and doesn't count. This is pure evil. Knowingly doing harm to people just for show. Trying to drive them out of the country to suit a racist and discriminatory agenda. It's done very cleverly to avoid targeting Muslim US citizens directly, but get them through collateral damage to their families and communities. But it's clear what he's trying to do.
I thought Hillary's comments about Trump supporters were excessive and counterproductive during the campaign. Not anymore. I'm done with Trump supporters. Supporting this man is supporting racism. It's supporting religious discrimination. I should thank him in a way, he's made this very simple.
- mythrwy 10y ago"Supporting this man is supporting racism" No it isn't. That's hyperbole and this isn't "racism".
- euyyn 10y agoHow is this ban not racist?
- grzm 10y agoArguably it's a matter of terminology, as I understand it. If the ban is targeting Muslims, it's a matter of religion, not race. If it's based on country, while it may be some form of prejudice, it's similarly not racism. That's my understanding of the argument, anyway. How would you describe it as being accurately described as "racism"? Please note I'm not taking a position on the ban here. I'm just trying to understand why people are using the language they are.
- simonh 10y agoIt's perfectly clear he's doing this for the purpose of religious discrimination. How do we know? Because he told us so clearly and directly during the primaries. His current VP described that as illegal and unconstitutional at the time. Arguably the specific legality of this precise formulation of the order avoids racism or religious discrimination. He's technically not targeting muslims. He's targeting people from Muslim majority countries and excepting christians. Whatever. Anyone arguing that is an apologist for racism and religious discrimination. Technicalities be damned.
- grzm 10y agoThanks for taking the time to respond. I understand a lot of the politics regarding the issue, and am specifically trying to avoid bringing that into this particular slice. I'm not arguing whether or not the ban is targeting Muslims. The recent Fox News interview leaves little room for doubt. The question 'euyyn had was "How is this ban not racist?" You bring up racism and religious discrimination. Do you draw a distinction between the two? I've started to suspect that the definition of racism is currently widening to encapsulate more than strictly racial prejudice. Your comment "Technicalities be damned." leads me to believe that your understanding of the term racism is this wider one. Personally I think racism is the wrong term; religious discrimination seems more apt. But I also understand language changes. I sincerely am not in any way trying to parse a way out of what the Executive Order represents or its intent. I just want to understand what people mean when they call it "racist".
- simonh 10y agoAre you going to, with a straight face, tell me that if these people were blonde and blue eyed that it would still be happening and be as acceptable as it is to far too many Americans.
- mistermann 10y ago> This ban clearly has nothing to do with terrorism > This order is pure racism and religious discrimination. I personally believe these outright bans have gone too far, but I continue to believe that while it's near impossible to remove emotion from these situations, we should always be open minded to facts, and wary of propaganda from either side of the political spectrum. Visitors from these countries were already designated as higher risk by the previous administration. So if it truly is "pure racism", then the former administration is guilty of the very same crime, but to a lesser degree. The ban is bad indeed, but the thinking behind the ban is the more important part in the big picture, is it not? Same thinking, different reaction. https://www.dhs.gov/news/2016/02/18/dhs-announces-further-travel-restrictions-visa-waiver-program https://www.dhs.gov/news/2016/02/18/dhs-announces-further-tr... https://www.cbp.gov/travel/international-visitors/visa-waiver-program/visa-waiver-program-improvement-and-terrorist-travel-prevention-act-faq https://www.cbp.gov/travel/international-visitors/visa-waive... "A" theory (and it's just that, a theory) of Trump's motive is presented near the bottom here: http://blog.dilbert.com/post/156532225711/the-persuasion-filter-and-immigration http://blog.dilbert.com/post/156532225711/the-persuasion-fil... "President Obama’s approach was to give a free pass to Islam in general and to any Muslims that were just minding their own business. But the unintended consequence is that Muslims have less incentive to police their own ranks. Trump changed that. Now if you want to stay out of the fight against terrorism it will cost you. So Trump has created a situation – or will soon – in which the peaceful Muslims will either have to do a lot more to help law enforcement find the terrorists in their midst or else live with an increasingly tainted brand. Trump is issuing no free passes for minding your own business. His model makes you part of the solution or part of the problem. No one gets to sit this one out. I’m not smart enough to know whether President Obama or President Trump have the best strategy in this regard. But both strategies are rational." Call me what you want, but I believe that every individual has a responsibility to police their fellow countrymen. We are here on this planet all by ourselves and we have to make things up as we go. You are free to believe differently, our standards and ethics aren't directives passed down from a God, it seems to me a lot of people have forgotten this. From where I sit, considering how many Muslims are still being killed on a regular basis in the last decade, the notion that trying a radical shake up of the status quo doesn't seem terribly "crazy" to me. I see so many pink elephants in the room, I'm not sure others are blind or I am crazy. I hope it works out for everyone, and soon.