3 ms·
The implication in the story is that the contract manufacturer made extras and sold them on the black market. How common is that? Does anybody know who made th
by criddell 10y ago
The implication in the story is that the contract manufacturer made extras and sold them on the black market. How common is that?
Does anybody know who made the phones?
- rbcgerard 10y agoI don't know how common it is when it comes to electronics, but it's quite common for many counterfeit goods, especially clothing/fashion
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 10y agoIt is a common strategy of manufacturers in China. You, as the designer, get ripped of by the very people that you pay to produce your product. The quality can match the original because they use the same factory, same tools, same processes that are used to produce the original product. The manufacturers simply work another shift, e.g. night shift, or do a few more runs. In some cases, manufacturers clone the whole factory that is used to produce the original product so they can increase output of counterfeit goods.
- jessaustin 10y agoHow could one prevent this? Would it be possible to only program a microcontroller after taking delivery, without which the circuit wouldn't be useful? Or could different components be sourced from different manufacturers, and then assembled in yet another factory? How much collusion between manufacturers should we expect?
- pavel_lishin 10y agoYou could push an OS update that bricks illegitimate phones :)
- kabdib 10y agoThis is why devices like game consoles and at least a few models of cell phones have a "geneology" database maintained by the official manufacturer, with originating key material in the hardware, and additional activating key material provided to the device at certain well-controlled manufacturing stations. You simply can't make a working device without going through that process. [Just bricking Blackphones is a terrible move; letting the users know their phones were counterfeit and leaving them on would have been a far better move, IMHO]
- criddell 10y agoSo if this is a known problem with known solutions, then the fact that Blackphone didn't do any of this makes them look like amateurs. Maybe one shouldn't rely on them for security...
- drewg123 10y agoI'm pretty sure that an android wear watch I bought on Ebay was grey market. I bought it for ~65% of the suggested retail price. When it died ~9 months later, its SN was not recognized by Motorola, so there was no warranty.