4 ms·
Same. Proprietary software provides unique encouragement for something to be created. In my experience, much of free-OSS has been significantly worse than a c
by Groxx 17y ago
Same. Proprietary software provides unique encouragement for something to be created. In my experience, much of free-OSS has been significantly worse than a cheap proprietary, if it exists at all.
"much", not "all" by any means. Some utterly, incomparably awesome stuff has come out as OSS.
- rdtsc 17y ago> In my experience, much of free-OSS has been significantly worse than a cheap proprietary, if it exists at all. For us, OSS has worked a lot better. Having the ability to inspect the source code all the way down to the hardware level, tweak it, adjust it, and share the fixes with the world is a lot better than waiting for that phone call back or that tech support email back. -- This is the practical benefit of OSS. It also appeals to those who want to understand how the system works, and those who dislike dealing with black-boxes that constantly break.
- sp332 17y agoOSS software junk may get better press than it deserves. But there are many, many times more proprietary software junk. e.g. http://cd.textfiles.com/directory.html http://cd.textfiles.com/directory.html
- Groxx 17y agoTo both / all replying to this: I'm not in any way claiming proprietary doesn't have crap. It's got loads of crap. But I'd be willing to bet that a large amount of the most used applications out there are proprietary, in many cases because there is no comparable OSS equivalent. And remember that the deciding factor in many cases is user interface - the average user does not care if they can hack it. Many many many OSS projects which could be contenders have absolutely abysmal UI and help documents.
- tome 17y agoI'd be willing to bet that a large amount of the most used applications out there are proprietary, in many cases because there is no comparable OSS equivalent. Your argument would be significantly stronger if you actually gave examples here.
- Groxx 17y agoPhotoshop - Gimp can't handle tablet input on any system I've got (lags horribly behind input), and is generally slower and has a horrendous UI which frequently puts windows half off-screen and sometimes cuts off text. Maya / 3DS Max / Whatever - Are you really going to claim Blender is any good? Functional, sure, but that's about it. Windows - Linux graphics drivers are often an absolute joke, so Windows really is just about the only real PC gaming option. And don't claim it's because graphics cards are closed hardware - then why hasn't an open-hardware group made anything competitive? Their only major success has been the Arduino (a BIG success, but rather lonely). OSX - Linux OSes, even Ubuntu, have all had clunky UI and seriously lacking normal-user help documentation. Last time I used Ubuntu, I had to resort to the CLI inside of 30 minutes to correct a permissions error the UI could only inform me of. Try telling most people how to do that. Outlook / Mail.app - Thunderbird's the biggest contender, and has many things right... but while the new UI is much nicer, I ran into many display bugs in less than an hour of use, one of which resulted in my deleting an email I did not have selected (when I didn't hit delete). MS Office suite / iWork suite - OpenOffice has a UI lagging behind even MS Office, and in many of my uses has failed to have a working updater and lags behind my typing frequently. And then there's the preferences window... most people simply cannot understand 90% of that, and will be turned off the entire application by its mere existence. Half Life / Quake / Unreal Tournament / PC games of any kind - ? Console games of any kind - ? McAfee / Norton / AVG - ? ClamAV? Brought my system to a crawl last time I used it. Not that McAfee / Norton are much better there, but... And in the other corner, we have: Firefox / Chrome, Pidgin / Adium (though Pidgin has a bad install process and a nasty UI for most people), Eclipse (though it's slow)... I know there are more, but I'm having trouble coming up with them right now. Just woke up. I had generally thought the major ones were self-explanatory, and this is rather long, hence its initial omission.