3 ms·
> Here's a better approach to drug users: catch them, sentence them to mandatory cold-turkey rehab, don't let them out until they're clean. Treating drug use a
by DanBC 10y ago
> Here's a better approach to drug users: catch them, sentence them to mandatory cold-turkey rehab, don't let them out until they're clean.
Treating drug use as a criminal justice problem rather than a public health problem is more expensive and gives worse results.
I think it's weird to ask tax payers to fund a very much more expensive programme (of police officers catching heroin users; of courts prosecuting them; of prisons holding them) especially when that programme has provably worse results (more harm to drug users; more harm to society; more cost to society) than treating drug use as a public health problem and providing harm reduction measures.
- thilmo 10y agoThe point of the criminal justice approach isn't to save the lives of those who have already taken heroin, but to save the lives of those who might be considering taking heroin. The harsher the punishment for heroin use, the more likely people are to get it into their heads not to fucking start taking heroin in the first place. On the other hand, if you make heroin addiction a free ticket to lots of health care and attention and "poor schnukkums" then you actually incentivise people who are already having a bad time to get on the heroin-addict train.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The harsher the punishment for heroin use, the more likely people are to get it into their heads not to fucking start taking heroin in the first place. Except it doesn't seem to work efficiently at that in the real world. > On the other hand, if you make heroin addiction a free ticket to lots of health care and attention and "poor schnukkums" then you actually incentivise people who are already having a bad time to get on the heroin-addict train. If it doesn't give any benefit beyond dealing with the harms of heroin addiction there is no actual incentive.
- DanBC 10y agoWe still see heroin addicts in countries that have a death penalty for heroin use, so harsh punishment clearly isn't working.