6 ms·
To clarify my original comment - when someone claims they can memorize a certain text, the way to verify the claim is to find the text. If you check the content
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
To clarify my original comment - when someone claims they can memorize a certain text, the way to verify the claim is to find the text. If you check the content, but not the source, you are only checking half the claim.
Why is it important to check the source? For the same reason that, when someone adds a reference to a paper, or a wikipedia article, people will often follow the reference and look for where it is exactly that it says what the referrer says it does- and complain if it turns out it doesn't.
So, for instance, if I mention that the minimax algorithm runs in time exponential to the number of nodes in a game tree, and you ask me how I know, and I reply that I read it in the 3d ed. of "AI: A modern approach" by Russel and Norvig, you are well within your rights to open the book, search for this information and, if you fail to find it, ask me whether I'm sure I got my refs right.
And that is true regardless of whether my claim about the running time is true or not- because that's only half the claim. The moment you add a reference your claim goes from "X is true" to "X is stated to be true in Y" and you have to be able to prove that "X is stated to be true in Y", not just that "X is true". And if "X is stated to be true in Y" is not true, but you go on to assume "X is true", then any other claim you make after that is up in the air, because you haven't yet told us how you know that X is true.
Which is important to know, because once you screw up your facts, as you inevitabley will, you (and everyone else) can at least trace your error back to all the things that you know, and the sources you drew that knowledge from, and have a glimmer of a hope to identify the error in your thinking.
Accordingly- if someone claims that "I memorised X from Y", you can check that X is stated in Y. If it is, then fine. If not, not fine.