Don't know if my memory is failing me, but it seems like Google re-enabled my search history some time in 2015 without telling me. Maybe around that time, sear

Don't know if my memory is failing me, but it seems like Google re-enabled my search history some time in 2015 without telling me. Maybe around that time, search history got subsumed by this newer "Web & App Activity" setting. You may want to re-check your settings.