5 ms·
"So I see attempts to diminish it as being ultimately pointless." Step one: Keep the patient alive. The welfare state crushing the economy is the worst case sc
by jerf 17y ago
"So I see attempts to diminish it as being ultimately pointless."
Step one: Keep the patient alive. The welfare state crushing the economy is the worst case scenario.
It doesn't matter how wonderful free health care, glorious welfare benefits, or anything else is if we can't afford it. "Can't afford it", at this level, is not merely a statement that we aren't trying hard enough. It is a statement that we physically lack the resources to follow through on the promises being made.
Our task is not to design the best economy we can have with ten times the resources we have. Those economies are irrelevant because they can not exist. (Yet, but when we do reach that time we will still have to work with what we have, not what we wish we had.) The task is to design the best economy we can have with the resources we have now. Sitting here and pining for the economy we can't have is bad enough, committing to building it nonetheless is simply death.
The critical thing that absolutely everyone is going to have to realize is that whatever horrible reaction you have to this point is not due to me, and shooting the messenger won't help. It is simply the way things are. It is reality. Denying reality will have the usual consequences.
It turns out that the people who said the welfare state is a bad idea may have been racist, may have wanted poor people to die, may have been heartless, may have been selfish, may have been any number of the bad nasty words thrown at them, but they were also right.
Your other identified problems are totally correct, and it's worth talking about solutions to them that don't involve sacrificing our entire civilization. I don't know what they are. But the welfare state has failed. Past tense. We're in the beginning of the end, but the bell has tolled and it will not be salvaged in anything like the form it has now. The only question is whether we commit civilizational suicide over that fact, or find something that does work.
(A lesser welfare state may well be the answer, but something is going to have to be done about the incentives for politicians and welfare recipients to grow the welfare state with no meaningful countervailing interest, which includes everyone who has been receiving more money that was justified by their actual work, including things like teachers and auto line workers. Something has to contain the rate of growth of welfare to the rate of growth of the economy itself. Something that allows it to go negative if it has to. Something strong enough that Congress can't just pass a law to increase things 10% this year. I have no idea what this could be.)
(Edit: Modding me down is just shooting the messenger. It is objective truth that we can not afford the path we are currently on. It's pretty close to objective truth that even just shrinking it today, but leaving in place the same incentives that led to our unsustainable course won't help much. It's not even terribly tricky math.)