3 ms·
Media pricing is currently pathological. Even for printed books the cost of production is relatively minor compared to the total price, and the artists tend to
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
Media pricing is currently pathological. Even for printed books the cost of production is relatively minor compared to the total price, and the artists tend to take away a relatively small portion of total revenue.
If a book costs 10x as much to produce or has 1/100th the sales as another book that has almost no effect on the overall pricing.
Unfortunately, consumers now expect books (and CDs and movies) to have flat, wholesale-style pricing. As if they were a commodity. Worse yet we have this bizarre hard back / paper back staged release process for books used to extract profit for in demand books. A model which doesn't work at all for ebooks.
I don't know what the answer is and I suspect that consumers may be too inflexible, at least in the near term, to allow for much price variability on ebooks. If that's the case then we may end up in a very bad situation for authors and new literature in general for a very long time.
- bobbyi 17y agoThe hardback/ paperback model is that early adopters are charged more and then the price is brought down later for people who are willing to wait. I don't see why that couldn't work for ebooks if people were willing to accept it.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoThe problem is that consumers are likely to reject, or be upset by, paying more for an identical version. If book publishers got rid of hardbacks and started introducing paperbacks at the same retail price as hardbacks used to cost, the market would probably not respond well. With ebooks it's even worse, since a lot of benefits of books (ability to loan and resell, quality of layout and production, etc.) are lost for ebooks and not necessarily made up for by some of the increases in convenience. I don't think a simplistic initial price premium is the answer to this problem but I also don't know what the answer is.
- kgermino 17y agoYes, that's why the publishers do it but they get away with it because many people see a hardback book as being more valuable than a paperback one despite the fact that they both cost about the same to make. Sure the only people who regularly but hardbacks are early adopters but they don't see themselves as paying extra because they are early adopters they see themselves as paying extra because their buying a better quality hardback book. This is different from a tech early adopter who knows that they are paying extra for the same thing in order to have it first. Yes it could work if people accepted it but I don't see people accepting it without there being something extra (maybe a forward from the author where the story only version of the book isn't released for a few weeks) that they can justify paying extra for.
- Tichy 17y agoOne reviewer mentioned it, though: you can give a paper book to a friend, sell it on ebay and what not. So even if production costs are neglectible in both cases (?don't know), the paper book is still worth more than the ebook.
- MWinther 17y agoWell, not necessarily. You could argue that the ebook is searchable, for instance, which the paper book is not. So I would say that the paper book and the ebook each have a few unique merits that might or might not be worth paying extra for. For me personally, the ebook advantage value for fiction does not equal the advantage value for a paper book, at least not yet, so for me, the ebook would have to be cheaper. I can imagine that for a reference book the equation might be different, though, at least using an e-book reader I'm happy with.
- dpapathanasiou 17y agoThat's true only if the e-book has DRM. It's one of the reasons we don't apply DRM to our books as a matter of policy.
- Tichy 17y agoNot having DRM makes it legal to pass on the ebook? Or do you also grant that license?
- dpapathanasiou 17y agoLicenses are up to the individual authors; some allow it, others don't. But in a DRM environment like Amazon, the point is moot.
- ahoyhere 17y agoI agree with everything you say -- and I'd like to add that the reasons people who buy things treat books like commodities, is because publishers do. Everybody's heard about that practice where unsold books have their covers ripped off, & are just thrown away. The publishers handily put a notice about that in the front of the book. If that doesn't make something a commodity, what does? On top of everything else, everybody with a Kindle who's bought more than a couple books has noticed that over 30% of them have horrible, amateurish formatting & OCR/character replacement errors. And on top of that, at least in the tech/nonfiction industry, publishers have drastically cut back resources & services offered to authors. O'Reilly, for example, wasn't planning on paying anyone to tech edit my book. They were hoping for volunteers, at a chapter apiece, instead of one person with a consistent viewpoint thru-out. That screws authors and it screws readers even more. As a person who did paid tech editing work for Que, Sams, McGraw-Hill & other publishers I can't even remember, I found this ludicrous. (And those publishers regularly told me I did the best work they ever had, which is saying something. Furthermore, I know most of my changes were never incorporated, probably because they "took too much time.") Basically, publishers are shitting where they eat & are too stupid to realize it, or too terrified to admit it, and instead, they are crowing about how the "consumer" is stupid, horrible, no good, very bad, and just damned stubborn.