3 ms·
Depends on how you define need. If you want to have a common open standard - absolutely. Same as with HTML instead of some ActiveX abomination. But if you want
by shmerl 10y ago
Depends on how you define need. If you want to have a common open standard - absolutely. Same as with HTML instead of some ActiveX abomination. But if you want to have balkanized lock-in mess, then it's a different story.
As long as MS has the notion of lock-in going on, I don't buy this whole "reformed" MS story.
- rubber_duck 10y agoI don't get what you're trying to say. Vulkan needs nothing from MS it's purely a driver thing, as for MS using DX over it I guess Vulkan is far too new and DX is proven and something you control (I wouldn't bet my core platform tech on something done by a committee either, maybe once it's a defacto standard), meanwhile GL is garbage compared to it, talk a aout Balkanization, good luck writing dx11 level features that work across two GL drivers.
- cwyers 10y agoshmerl mentions Vulkan on every thread he possibly can, it feels like. It's his hobbyhorse. I think an Xbox owes him money or something.
- pjmlp 10y agoWithout having any understanding what people on the games industry actually care about.
- shmerl 10y agoAnd you apparently represent those who profit from lock-in. Is that why you justify it all the time? Because no one would objectively do it. I never saw an engineer who said "lock-in is good, more lock-in please!". Those who do it, are backwards thinking managers like the one from this quote: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Microsoft#Vendor_lock-in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Microsoft#Vendor_...
- pjmlp 10y agoNo, I represente those that have real life experience in the industry, and don't care one little second about lock-in, because the industry learned to profit from it since the early 80's. - game studios specializing in ports among hardware platforms - consultants doing optimization work in specific APIs - hardware platforms that offer an unique experience in terms of gameplay, due to their CPU and GPU architectures, that no portable 3D ever exposed, not even Vulkan (hence NVN on Switch) - middleware engines that allow for portability, while providing access to all hardware features, with better debugging tools that so called portable APIs ever had Your problema is that no one in the industry, the people that actually pay for tickets to attend GDC and similar conferences not weekend indie devs, don't see lock-in as a burden, rather as a way to make the game exclusive and sell their IP. Which incidently is something I bet you also don't agree with, the way IP is managed throughtout the industry. Once upon a time I did think like that, during my FOSS/GNU/Linux phase, then I had the opportunity to have a glimpse how the industry works from the inside, not how people think they should. Are you aware that even Intel is not putting that much effort on their Vulkan drivers for Windows?
- shmerl 10y ago> No, I represente those that have real life experience in the industry, and don't care one little second about lock-in An oxymoron. Those who care about the industry understand perfectly well, how lock-in is a problem for it. It's like saying that MS cared about the Web so much, that they pushed ActiveX, to benefit it. Dan Baker (from Oxide) wrote[1] about problems of lock-in and need for portability in computer graphics. And don't try claiming he doesn't know about the industry, he is one of the creators of DirectX itself. Oxide put their words in action, and were involved in Mantle creation, and naturally participate in the Vulkan working group. > don't see lock-in as a burden, rather as a way to make the game exclusive and sell their IP. Which incidently is something I bet you also don't agree wit Yes, I see exclusivity as a stinking practice. Why would creator want to exclude some users on purpose? Normal creator tries the opposite, to reach as many users as possible. Only backwards thinking legacy publishers don't do that. But they aren't equal to creators. Also, normal creators don't call their art "IP". Just a hint for you, whom you really represent. 1. http://www.oxidegames.com/2014/05/21/next-generation-graphics-apis/ http://www.oxidegames.com/2014/05/21/next-generation-graphic...
- shmerl 10y ago> I don't get what you're trying to say. Then analyze what happened with HTML and ActiveX. Draw parallels, and you'll understand what I'm trying to say.