4 ms·
Separation of powers is a fundamental principle of the U.S. Constitution. There's no guarantee that the legislature will be favorable to your positions either.
by nostrademons 10y ago
Separation of powers is a fundamental principle of the U.S. Constitution. There's no guarantee that the legislature will be favorable to your positions either. If you're of a liberal, progressive, or even moderate bent, the past 6 years would've been much worse had Obama not been a check on the Republican Congress.
Since 1980, periods when both the Presidency and both houses of Congress have been under the control of one party have been quite rare, and the public usually votes out one house of Congress in the next election. Democrats in 09-10, Republicans from 02-06, Democrats in 92-94, and that's it.
(Interestingly, this is not universal throughout history. Dem's controlled both houses of Congress and the presidency under the Wilson, FDR, Truman, Kennedy, Johnson, and Carter administrations, while Republicans controlled them during the Mckinley, Teddy Roosevelt, Taft, Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover administrations. The last extended time period of divided control was the post-Reconstruction Gilded Age era from 1875-1897...perhaps leading credence to those who say the current time period is much more like the Long Depression, Gilded Age, and lead up to WW1 than the Great Depression and lead-up to WW2.)
- mseebach 10y agoWhat we have now isn't separation of power, it's immense power of the office of the president. The president should be a check on Congress (which he is), but Congress should also be a check on the president (they're not, effectively, because they have handed over so much power to him). The same power that made Obama good to progressives will make Trump very, very bad to them.
- throwaway4job 10y agoI strongly believe that Obama was net good in large part because there was so much opposition to him. As such he couldn't ram-rod a one-sided version of anything through. Similarly, I feel that Bush's and Clinton's best years were the periods where they had opposition, and couldn't use party allegiance to push things through. I've felt that one-sided rule is net-negative essentially every time it's happened in my adult life, regardless of party. Trump will just be an especially hard to ignore version of this anti-pattern, as he's made clear that he'll punish non-conformity within the GOP; and the GOP has made clear that they will do anything he requests, even when it stands against every major conservative principle.
- nostrademons 10y agoI'd argue that they are a check on the President. Wasn't the main objection to Obama that he didn't actually accomplish much of the "Change" he promised during his presidency? Most of that is because he had an opposition Congress that obstructed every major policy change. Much of the rest is because the President doesn't actually have the power most people think he does - he is largely powerless to positively influence the economy, for example, and he's completely unable to predict or control technological breakthroughs that may throw millions of people out of work.
- brianwawok 10y agoWhere is the line between "Check to prevent abuse" and "Roadblock that stops any meaningful change"?
- mseebach 10y agoCongress legislates, president implements. The president isn't where "meaningful change" should come from. Hence 'king-complex'.
- anigbrowl 10y agoAnd Congress frequently legislates to delegate - entirely in accordance with the Constitution, which is why article II section 2.1 contemplate the President 'requir[ing] the Opinion, in writing, of the principal Officer in each of the executive Departments, upon any subject relating to the duties of their respective Offices.' Clearly, the framers contemplated the existence of Departments within the executive branch, whose Officers held Opinions about things within their purview, as opposed to being mindless robots. A great deal of legislation sets the scope and limits of such departmental authority, while directing the departments to engage in a more detailed rulemaking process of their own as opposed to everything being micromanaged by Congress. You keep making normative statements that describe your personal political views, but I can't help noticing that you're not citing any provisions in the Constitution to back up your argument. I'm thus unsure whether you are talking about your view of the Constitution's meaning or some other scheme of governance with which you'd like to replace the existing one.
- anigbrowl 10y agoThis is nonsensical. I consider Obama to have been a good President because I liked his policy proposals, not because he of his ability to wield executive power (the bulk of which was inherited from his predecessors, by the way). You talk as if Obama ignored Congress, which is simply not the case.