47 ms·
Based on the European Commission's guide to Privacy Shield document, it does not appear that Trump's order affects it. Privacy Shield sets requirements for how
by tzs 10y ago
Based on the European Commission's guide to Privacy Shield document, it does not appear that Trump's order affects it.
Privacy Shield sets requirements for how US companies must deal with personal data that they transfer from the EU to the US. These requirements are:
1. The company must inform you about:
- the types of personal data it processes,
- the reasons is processes personal data,
- if it intends to transfer your data to another company and why,
- your right to ask for access to your personal data,
- your opt-out right to having the data used in a way "materially different" or disclosed to another company,
- how to contact the company if you have a complaint about the use of your data,
- the dispute resolution body in the EU or US where you can bring a complaint,
- the US government agency that is responsible for investigating and enforcing these obligations,
- the possibility that the company may have to respond to lawful requests from US public authorities to disclose information about you.
2. If the company wants to use your personal data for a different purpose than the one for which it was originally collected or has been subsequently authorized by you:
- this is not allowed if the new purpose is incompatible with the original purpose,
- if the new purpose is different but related to the original, they may only do so if you do not object (but in the case of "sensitive data" you have to actually consent).
- if the new different purpose is close enough to not be considered "materially different" the use is permitted.
3. They should only receive and process personal data to the extend that is relevant for the purpose of processing, and only keep it as long as necessary for this, with some exceptions allowing longer keeping for the public interest, journalism, literature and art, scientific or historical research, or statistical analysis.
4. The company must secure the data.
5. Protect the data if transferred to another company.
6. Provide you with access to your data and a way to request corrections.
Trump's order says that agencies, which means Federal government agencies, have to exclude from their privacy policies people who are not US citizens and not lawful permanent residents.
These agency privacy policies were not covered under Privacy Shield, and so this change to them appears to be irrelevant to Privacy Shield. It doesn't change the obligations of companies under Privacy Shield.
Note that I'm basing this analysis on a document written by the EU to explain Privacy Shield to ordinary citizens. It is possible that there are subtleties or complexities that they left out of that document that may be relevant.
- mtgx 10y agoI'm not sure how accurate that is that it doesn't affect agencies at all. The whole reason the old Safe Harbor deal fell at the CJEU was because of Snowden's documents and accusations that US is indiscriminately accessing European's data through companies.