6 ms·
> We need to wake the fuck up in the EU ...and stop trying to dismantle it from the inside because money and too much regulation. it's in chinese, russian and
by baq 10y ago
> We need to wake the fuck up in the EU
...and stop trying to dismantle it from the inside because money and too much regulation. it's in chinese, russian and US interests for the EU countries to negotiate independently, but certainly not in europe's interest at large.
- riprowan 10y agoIn fact, at this moment, a united Europe may represent the last significant hope for Western liberal democracy. Past Europe, the superpowers are USA, Russia, China...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mike-cardwell 10y agoSo, super powers aren't working out for the people they govern, so the solution is to create another super power? Centralising political power might not actually be the best thing for "the people". Might be good for GDP though, which I guess is more important? </s>
- kuschku 10y agoSo, who is rather able to defend privacy rights when the Chinese or American megacorporations come? Iceland, with its 300'000 citizen? Or the EU, with 500'000'000 citizen, a GDP of 17 trillion? The only way to police corporations is by having a state that is more powerful than them. And with corporations going multinational, superpowers are necessary.
- orbifold 10y agoExcept in many ways the EU was conceived by US planners to eliminate popular control and provide a negotiating partner for the US that could be dealt with as a whole. The EU is far less democratic and more friendly to corporations and neo-liberalism than ~50% of the national parties in Europe, which often contain a significant democratic-socialist block.
- touristtam 10y agoAs much as I understand this narative, it makes sounds like the europeans have not been in control of their own destiny since the fatal events of the last century. But that is giving way too much credit to USA's federal government, where in fact this should be recognized as the triumph of corporation control over states.
- doikor 10y ago> The EU is far less democratic All the people in the controlling bodies (well at least the places that should be voted for. Voting for judges etc. is madness) in EU are appointed by the member nations (either by vote or appointed) European Council: Heads of state of the member nations (president chosen by vote within) European Commission: One member appointed by each country (so usually someone from the ruling coalition within each country). Sworn to represent the benefits of EU as a whole and not single countries. President proposed by the Council and voted on by the Parliament European Parliament: Members chosen by vote from each country. President (speaker) voted within. So both executive and legislative levels are voted in or representatives of a democratically chosen government. Looks like democracy to me.
- richmarr 10y agoI'm pro-EU but there's plenty to be unhappy about. For example the European Parliament can't introduce legislation... that power is reserved for the European Commission, which seems to use it in a particularly pro-lobbyist manner.
- candiodari 10y agoYou forgot to mention that the commission can also bypass the parliament to get laws approved, in the emergency procedure the commission and the council approve legislation.
- doikor 10y agoBut both are still filled by people appointed by democratic governments of member states. And still that only applies to handling "a financial crisis" by giving aid to member state(s) and needs qualified majority (85% in this case so 24 out of 28 votes in both the Council and Commission). Basically how the Council has been setup is that you usually need a unanimous or 20 out of 28 votes to get anything done.
- angry-hacker 10y agoEuropeans don't want liberal democracy anymore, that is the problem. It has failed people in its form and if leaders don't wake up now, the EU will be doomed and who knows what that brings next. Brexit, Le Pen etc. are consequences, not the reason.
- richmarr 10y ago> Europeans don't want liberal democracy anymore, that is the problem. A little hyperbolic, but true if you add a ton of caveats. In the UK people have been subjected to a 25-year barrage of anti-EU sentiment from the tabloid press, that's frequently misleading or outright untrue. For example, the (entirely fabricated) front-page headline that the EU wanted to ban all bent bananas, and more recently that the EU wanted to ban bananas from being sold in bunches of more than 2 or 3. Retractions are published in small print on page 27.
- angry-hacker 10y agoI don't think it has anything to do with bananas. Brussels have too much power and byrocracy. It's mainly about mass immigration. EU was meant to be about trade and free movement inside our borders, not some EU super state and Brussels telling what to do. People want nation states, no one voted for mass immigration. You can say racist all you want but that doesn't change the fact.
- Oletros 10y agoTo understand your point, in what mass migration are you thinking about? And what EU policy allowed it?
- angry-hacker 10y agoMerkel/Brussels/EU telling how to handle refugees, how many should (independent) EU state take them, when etc. People don't like it or want it. They want to decide decisions like that on their own.
- skocznymroczny 10y agoIt's not in Europe's interest to destroy nation states and replace ethnic Europeans with non-verified nationals from "risky" countries.
- baq 10y agoof course it's not.
- candiodari 10y agoYou forget the circumstances. Once you take into consideration that these locals have had a fertility rate of 1.7 or so on average for 20 years you see the deal : Without mass immigration (I don't mean the last 2 years, I mean "normal" mass immigration) the EU would have lost slightly over 5% of it's population by now, and it would accelerate. The net numbers don't even tell the whole story, as lots of countries are now seeing net-negative growth even given mass immigration. Something like 10% of 20-30 year youths have left and have been replaced by these immigrants. Now the numbers matter less than the reality, yes population would drop, but ... without mass immigration, without these poor Africans with little language knowledge the minimum wage in countries like Germany would be 50% higher or more. If you walk through a city like Berlin and look at restaurant staff, street cleaners, ... what do you see ? France ? Same thing (despite the government rhetoric I might add). The Netherlands ? Even worse. Without mass immigration these countries would have gone into Japan-style stagnation and perma-recession over a decade ago. The funny thing is, of course this was only a delay. We are very close to the point where global numbers will start to drop, and frankly, population numbers are already dropping pretty much everywhere outside of sub-Saharan Africa (all sorts of fun facts come up. Do you know that the largest group of Christians will be all-black in less than a decade ? In two decades they will be easily double the next ethnicity (either white or Chinese). And "black" black, you know, with the massive lips, somewhat larger eyes, distinct difference in skin color on palms and soles, ... A black pope isn't nearly as far off as people think) Now keep in mind what this does and does not mean : first and foremost it means more pensioners, less savings, and much less people involved in actual economic activity (already very noticeable in Western Europe). Note that this is unfixable, for at least 30 years. If today every family suddenly decided to have seven kids, economic population would only start increasing in something like 20-30 years (because it takes a while to actually make 7 kids). We would still see all the effects of population decrease for a period that is probably half the remaining lifespan for most of us (in fact slightly more since kids are also dependents, also a drain on savings, ...) Even with the total disastrous immigration Europe is now seeing, actual population growth in the EU is still muted at best. Eastern Europe, especially, is bleeding dry of people at an astonishing rate.